natural theology

We have just published a new book that summarizes the ideas of this site. Free at Scientific Theology, or, if you wish to support this project, buy at Scientific Theology: A New Vision of God

Contact us: Click to email
vol VII: Notes

2016

Notes

Sunday 18 September 2016 - Saturday 24 September 2016

[Notebook: DB 80: Cosmic plumbing]

Sunday 18 September 2016

[page 240]

Monday 19 September 2016
Pure pornography: representation of people enjoying sex without political, racist, sexist or abusive context. (frame: 'sluts are doing their evil thing')

Classical electrodynamics: charge = propensity to communicate (so a force). Propensity / potential = rate of execution of electromagnetic codec.

Tuesday 20 September 2016

Thompson: The root of all our troubles is that we worship the wrong god. Sean Thompson

The transfinite network can execute any possible mathematical proof from the point of view of both communication and computability.

COMMUNICATION <=> COMPUTABILITY

The whole book is an attempt to explain this identification (formal) and its consequences, both as a fit to history and a bridge to the future that models the real bridge to the future in the Universe that enables us to predict elements of the future from the past, eg that the Earth will still be here in 4 billion years time, inhabited no doubt by our children's children's . . .

[page 241]

Insight: Thinking about buying a pressure gauge I realize that I can use the GPS feature of the iphone to measure the height of the header tank. The pressure gauge would also give real time data on the amount of water in the header tank.

Writing : coding :: communication : computation

I have sometimes resented the need to follow a trade in order to survive but now I see it as my theological laboratory, since it requires me to deal practically with everything from physics to the credit worthiness od potential customers. Like Galileo (!) an interface between science and technology.

In physics we create mathematical phase spaces, state spaces and function spaces in general and then seek to constrain these universal spaces down to the systems we actually observe: not 'all mathematically possible particles' but the 60 or so fundamental particle that we actually observe. In the transfinite computer network the formal limit is computability per se, but in the real phsical world time of of the essence, and if the process can not be completed in the available time with the available resources then it is practically incomputable and the outcome of the potential computation is a matter of chance.

The transfinite computer network embodies self pruning, that is natural selection and so can create itself.

[page 242]

The physical order in a line must be maintained by bonding between the points. If this bonding does not see the individual identities of the bonded particles, then they can freely permute with one another - every permutation is equiprobable, a continuum of probabilities.

Quantum mechanics is all a matter of local timing / phase. It is local because it exists before the emergence of space so that the only differentiation is events marking the passage of time.

Wednesday 21 September 2016

Engineering and metaphysics.

Back to computer-network, rename computer_universe, rename network_universe.

So to 'network_universe'
Why is the universe quantized? To defeat error.
What does quantum mechanics predict? The form and frequency of messages in the universal network.

Extracting information from the universe and interpreting it.

[page 243]

We build a good society by detecting and correcting error is existing society. By errors we mean circumstances preventing people exercising the full spectrum of human right guaranteed by the Universal Declaration of human rights.

Layers are defined by their peers.

I will enter academia when my investments come good. In the meantime I can economize and even save a little bit by working from home. I would like to socialize but I would have to move to a high rent area to go to university.

Domestic violence may arise when people are bound by the strong potentials of reproduction which not being otherwise suited to one another. An irretrievable breakdown should probably lead to divorce so a couple are not imprisoned in a bad situation.

Lungs: trees of blood and air brought into correspondence in the alveoli, the tips of the branches. Bit like government, tax and sped through corresponding trees [we are the leaves].

The most embarrassing time in my life. I knew no girls. My friends found someone to be my partner at the prefects dance but I went away and did not meet her, and went to the dance alone. Must have been something to do with my pre-monastic upbringing since now (only 55 years later) I get on well with women.

Thursday 22 September
Friday 23 September 2016

[page 244]

Everyone is entitled to a voice, that is a vote and accompanying speech. The fundamental attack on humans rights is denial of the vote or elements of the voting procedure.

Rights — respect. Fermions respect one another?

Happiness comes with a flow of ideas, insight, mental orgasm.

The big job now is to establish an interface between the model and the day to day information we receive and experience of the events in the world ranging from murder to childbirth.

Traditionally virtue is considered to be a narrow path with vices on each side.

Aquinas: 'Moral virtue perfects the appetitive part of the soul by directing it to good as defined by reason. III, 59. 4. Aquinas, I II, 59, 4: Are all moral virtues about passions?

Drutman. Lee Drutman: The Divided States of America

I fell far from the tree. In a solid professional family I became first a priest, then an activist, then a hippy and now am spending my older years trying to put theology on a realistic foundation.

We are all leaves on the human tree and are coupled back through the braches to our common root. From a software point of view, we are all children of god.

[page 245]

The thin line of virtue, if we think of optimally rational behaviour, is mapped by computability, ie it follows the engineering route rather than a guess or uncertainty. This idea of virtue connects with Aquinas' view of divine determinism tempered by human free will, where the ideal path for the will (geodesic) follows the divine will, manifest in the potentials of the world, exactly.

The Cantorian extension of Hilbert Space. The permutations of the vectors of the countable Hilbert space gives us the second transfinite Hilbert space and so on. I am a non-mathematical trying to appropriate the language of mathematics to express a theological idea.

Where are the weak spots in the line of descent from the traditional gods to the divine universe? We concentrate here on the Catholic god as a clear and well defined model of god, and one central to the theological tradition which I am seeking to replace.

Do I take myself seriously? Not so much. I do think the Catholic Church can be improved, but I am not inclined to be an activist (ie committed) but only a researcher open to seeing a new version of God.

We can improve an existing system by tweaking its performance here and there but there often coes a time when a radical change is needed to achieve the desired ends by removing perverse incentives and other problems leading to performance failure [eg the Church's view that it is above the law has led it to hide the criminal activities of many of its clergy]. So we replace piston engines in aircraft with turbines, beginning a new

[page]

line of development. So replace witchdoctors with universal [evidence based] health care. David Marr: Farrell puts Catholic Church's atitude to Australian law under the microscope

Saturday 24 September 2016

network-universe: In a sense it is perfectly obvious. Everything, ie all events, are the outputs of the underlying process of communication which we currently understand as the evolution of a gigantic wave function which operates in a transfinite Hilbert space. Insofar as this activity is deterministic we model it with error free (ie digital) computers. In a way I am now bored with it and need a holiday of some sort to build up steam to do the writing. It is interesting that now that physical labour is becoming a bit of a struggle, writing is going the same way, so I need to get onto both finishing the house and writing my story while I am still young. The time constant for the creation and annihilation of humans is about a century.

The reality of the network seems assured and it becomes (in Aquinas' terms) the new standard of rationality and hence (again with Thomas) the new standard toward which virtue tends. This is an echo of the deterministic view. We add the indeterministic which is based on the fact that that most functions [from the natural numbers to themselves] are incomputable and therefore may lead to destructive outcomes (errors) which must be prevented where possible by careful attention to the failure modes of random events. Here is where the mathematical theory

[page 247]

of communication [becomes useful], a form of statistical mechanics adapted to sources whose alphabets have unequal frequency, ie less than maximum entropy.

Now some excitement draws me on: the theory of communication teaches us how to be deterministic in a random world. We note that in current political discourse concern for true communication has been obscured by deception and spin, and this corruption is leading to a breakdown in high level political structures while the lower levels forge ahead whenever the opportunity presents. Here we find truth and accountability [ie engineering]. Nicholas Kristof: The Best News You Don't know

Am I born to revise Catholic theology? I think I think so, and have devoted as much of my time and money to this task [as possible] since I moved here in 1978. This does not, of course, guarantee good success.

We want to replace the fundamental equation ∂φ / ∂t = Eφ, where E is a matrix, φ a vector, and the whole thing represents a flow of energy between different dimensions of ψ.

The 'layer significant' (like position significant) measurement of entropy. The amount of entropy in an act depends upon the layer in which it is executed. Positional notation - Wikipedia

'Mine eyes have seen the coming of the glory of the lord. A fantasy, a false hope for those who place their future in the hands of a Messiah instead of taking it into their own hands

There is only one person who can promote my vision of god and that is me.

[page 248]

Too much of the world is run by gutless little men who think that security lies in the ability to inflict violence.

The fu? (distracted to change the music volume) I've forgotten; its moved out of the space of my consciousness, and such a brilliant insight, a flash in the light of intellect. So come back. What as I thinking about? Hey Mr Tambourine Man. Bob Dylan

Syria: The government, no matter how bad, has the upper hand because it controls the army and the secret police and this advantage in violent power takes a lot of careful social and political construction to combat.

War is possible because people value some things more greatly than life, even if they are misguided by their environment.

The cognitive dissonance I experience in the Church had the effect of putting me into a state of suspended animation insofar as I have put much of my life on hold until I solved the theological question, and have been heavily constrained by the need to achieve this before I could relax and come alive again, Those days are approaching, I feel. My voice is coming back.

Physical difficulties can be difficult but metaphysical difficulties can be worse because the deny all grounds of recovery outside

[page 249]

of assistance from imaginary friends. I am beginning to hear music again.

Jesus wept. Jesus wept - Wikipedia

From dry formalism to living concert.

Some people seem to be secure from birth and easily find their voices. I feel that I have taken a very long way around.

'The wheel's still in spin.' Bob Dylan: The Times they are a-changin'

Copyright:

You may copy this material freely provided only that you quote fairly and provide a link (or reference) to your source.

Links
Aquias II, II 47, 1, Is prudence in the will or in reason?, 'I answer that, As Isidore says (Etym. x): "A prudent man is one who sees as it were from afar, for his sight is keen, and he foresees the event of uncertainties." Now sight belongs not to the appetitive but to the cognitive faculty. Wherefore it is manifest that prudence belongs directly to the cognitive, and not to the sensitive faculty, because by the latter we know nothing but what is within reach and offers itself to the senses: while to obtain knowledge of the future from knowledge of the present or past, which pertains to prudence, belongs properly to the reason, because this is done by a process of comparison. It follows therefore that prudence, properly speaking, is in the reason.' back
Aquinas, I II, 59, 4, Are all moral virtues about the passions?, 'I answer that, Moral virtue perfects the appetitive part of the soul by directing it to good as defined by reason. Now good as defined by reason is that which is moderated or directed by reason. Consequently there are moral virtues about all matters that are subject to reason's direction and moderation. Now reason directs, not only the passions of the sensitive appetite, but also the operations of the intellective appetite, i.e. the will, which is not the subject of a passion, as stated above (Question 22, Article 3). Therefore not all the moral virtues are about passions, but some are about passions, some about operations.' back
Australian Government, Children Care, 'What is out-of-home care? Out-of-home care refers to the care of children and young people up to 18 years who are unable to live with their families (often due to child abuse and neglect). It involves the placement of a child or young person with alternate caregivers on a short- or long-term basis (Victorian Department of Human Services, 2007). Out-of-home care can be arranged either formally or informally. Informal care refers to arrangements made without intervention by statutory authorities or courts, and formal care occurs following a child protection intervention (either by voluntary agreement or a care and protection court order). This paper will describe those children in out-of-home care in Australia who are on care and protection orders.' back
Binoy Kampmark, History will pardon Snowdon even of Obama won't, 'What Snowden revealed was a technology security complex inefficient yet invasive; global and indifferent to national borders and oversight. It also revealed the institutional bankruptcy between the public citizen and the global watchers; and stressed the enormous importance of taking self-help measures in guarding against hacking intrusions. There have never been better times for companies specialising in self-encryption, or discussion about a global bill of digital privacy. Even if Snowden receives no pardon from President Obama, he can at least be sure to have been pardoned, to a large extent, by history.' back
Bob Dylan, Hey Mr Tambourine Man (Live at the Newport Folk Festival 1964), back
Bob Dylan, The Times They Are A-Changin', 'Come writers and critics Who prophesize with your pen And keep your eyes wide The chance won’t come again And don’t speak too soon For the wheel’s still in spin And there’s no telling who that it’s naming For the loser now will be later to win For the times they are a-changing' back
Criticism of the theory of relativity - Wikipedia, Criticism of the theory of relativity - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia, 'Criticism of the theory of relativity of Albert Einstein was mainly expressed in the early years after its publication in the early twentieth century, on scientific, pseudoscientific, philosophical, or ideological bases.Though some of these criticisms had the support of reputable scientists, Einstein's theory of relativity is now accepted by the scientific community. Reasons for criticism of the theory of relativity have included alternative theories, rejection of the abstract-mathematical method, and alleged errors of the theory. . . . There are still some critics of relativity today, but their opinions are not shared by the majority in the scientific community.' back
David Marr, Farrell puts Catholic Church's atitude to Australian law under the microscope, 'The furrows deepened on the brow of Father Brian Lucas. . . . On one reading of this tangled story, Lucas could face possible criminal charges for failing to alert the police 24 years ago to the apparently frank confessions of a paedophile priest. He doesn’t see it that way. . . . Lucas matters. . . . The Farrell case is the commission’s last look at the role of the Catholic church. It’s no afterthought. This is the scandal that raises the fundamental question of the church’s attitude to Australian law. Is it a “good citizen” as Cardinal George Pell has so often claimed? Or does the church see itself as a separate realm answerable to the laws of Rome?' back
Dusko Pavlovic and Catherine Meadows, Actor-network procedures: Modelling multi-factorial authentication, device pairing, social interactions, 'Abstract. As computation spreads from computers to networks of compute rs, and migrates into cyberspace, it ceases to be globally programmable, but it remains programmable ind irectly and partially: network com- putations cannot be controlled, but they can be steered by imposin g local constraints on network nodes. The tasks of ”programming” global behaviors through local const raints belong to the area of security . The “program particles” that assure that a system of local interactio ns leads towards some desired global goals are called security protocols . They are the software connectors of modern, world wide softwa re systems. As computation spreads beyond cyberspace, into physical and so cial spaces, new security tasks and prob- lems arise. As computer networks are extended by nodes with phys ical sensors and controllers, including the humans, and interlaced with social networks, the engineering conc epts and techniques of computer security blend with the social processes of security, that evolved since the dawn of mankind. These new connectors for computational and social software require a new “discipline of p rogramming” of global behaviors through local constraints. Since the new discipline seems to be emerging from a combination of established models of security protocols with older methods of procedural programm ing, we use the name procedures for these new connectors, that generalize protocols. In the present paper we propose actor-networks as a formal model of computation in heterogenous net- works of computers, humans and their devices, where these new p rocedures run; and we introduce Procedure Derivation Logic (PDL) as a framework for reasoning about security in actor-netw orks. On the way, we survey the guiding ideas of Protocol Derivation Logic (also PDL) that evolved through our work in security in last 10 years. Both formalisms are geared towards graphic reaso ning and, ultimately, tool support. We illustrate their workings by analysing a popular form of two-factor a uthentication, and a multi-channel device pairing procedure, devised for this occasion.' back
Gwenda Tavan, If the normal rules of politial engaement don't apply, how do we handle Pauline Hanson?, 'She and her fellow travellers conform to what US historian Richard Hofstadter once referred to as “the paranoid style”. Hofstadter did not mean such people were clinically insane, rather that they were normal people motivated by tendencies towards acute exaggeration, suspiciousness and conspiratorial fantasy. History, Hofstadter pointed out, is peppered with individuals and groups who mobilised politically on the basis of their belief that their group was under direct threat from hostile forces intrinsically opposed to the “in-group’s” values and ideals.' back
Hannan Devlin, Indigenous Australians most ancient civilization on Earth, DNA study confirms, 'Scientists were able to trace the remarkable journey made by intrepid ancient humans by sifting through clues left in the DNA of modern populations in Australia and Papua New Guinea. The analysis shows that their ancestors were probably the first humans to cross an ocean, and reveals evidence of prehistoric liaisons with an unknown hominin cousin. . . . The findings appear in one of four major human origins papers published in Nature this week, which together give an unprecedented insight into how humans first migrated out of the African continent, splintered into distinct populations and spread across the globe.' back
History - Wikipedia, History - Wikipedia, the cree encyclopedia, 'History (from Greek ἱστορία, historia, meaning "inquiry, knowledge acquired by investigation") is the study of the past as it is described in written documents. Events occurring before written record are considered prehistory. It is an umbrella term that relates to past events as well as the memory, discovery, collection, organization, presentation, and interpretation of information about these events. Scholars who write about history are called historians.' back
History of religions - Wikipedia, History of religions - Wikipedia, the free encuclopedia, 'The history of religion refers to the written record of human religious experiences and ideas. This period of religious history begins with the invention of writing about 5,200 years ago (3200 BCE). The prehistory of religion relates to a study of religious beliefs that existed prior to the advent of written records.' back
Janissary - Wikipedia, Janissary - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia, 'The Janissaries (from Ottoman Turkish يڭيچرى Yeniçeri meaning "new soldier", Albanian: Jeniçer) were infantry units that formed the Ottoman sultan's household troops and bodyguards. The force was created by the Sultan Murad I from Christian boys levied through the devşirme system from conquered countries in the 14th century[1] and was abolished by Sultan Mahmud II in 1826 with the Auspicious Incident.' back
Jesus wept - Wikipedia, Jesus wept - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia, 'Jesus wept (Greek: ἐδάκρυσεν ὁ Ἰησοῦς) is a phrase famous for being the shortest verse in the King James Version of the Bible, as well as many other versions.' back
Lee Drutman, The Divided States of America, 'Most large cities, college towns, the Northeast and the West Coast are deep-blue Democratic. Ruby-red Republican strongholds take up most of the South, the Great Plains, the Mountain States and the suburban and rural areas in between. Rather than compete directly against each other, both parties increasingly occupy their separate territories, with diminishing overlap and disappearing common accountability. They hear from very different constituents, with very different priorities. The minimal electoral incentives they do face all push toward nurturing, rather than bridging, those increasingly wide divisions.' back
michael Westawy et al, DNA reveals a new history of the First Australians, 'The first few decades of modern archaeological research into Australia’s ancient past was conducted with very little to no involvement of Aboriginal Australian people. This was followed by decades of debate over ownership of the past. Initial DNA research proposals floundered because little to no consultation was undertaken. A new period of community based research with Aboriginal people was forged through the sensitive and highly consultative approach pioneered by geneticist Sheila Van Holst Pellekaan. Her work with Aboriginal people set the standard for later scientific studies in Australia.' back
Nicholas Kristof, The Best News You Don't know, '■ As recently as 1981, when I was finishing college, 44 percent of the world’s population lived in extreme poverty, according to the World Bank. Now the share is believed to be less than 10 percent and falling. “This is the best story in the world today,” says Jim Yong Kim, the president of the World Bank.' back
Pallavi Singhal, How early Aboritifnal Australians journeyed from Africa, '"We've tried to reconstruct this genetic map of Australia that tells a story of how dynamic Aboriginal society was over 50,000 years," said Michael Westaway, senior research fellow at Griffith University and co-author of the study, published in Nature./ back
Peter Kornbluh, Why the Obama administration is giving state secrets to Latin American allies, 'Alongside the traditional instruments of statecraft, the Obama administration has developed an entirely new tool: declassifying decades-old secrets of state to share with other governments and their societies. President Obama has used this declassification diplomacy to mend fences with other countries, advance the cause of human rights and even redress the dark history of Washington’s support for repression abroad. Allies are grateful and historians are delighted. And given the depth and range of still-secret U.S. Cold War records, declassified diplomacy has the potential to go much, much further.'
Peter Kornbluh is a senior analyst at the National Security Archive and the author of “The Pinochet File: A Declassified Dossier on Atrocity and Accountability.” back
Positional notation - Wikipedia, Positional notation - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia, 'Positional notation or place-value notation is a generalization of decimal notation to arbitrary base. These include binary (base 2) and hexadecimal (base 16) notations used by computers as well as the base 60 notation of Babylonian numerals. The deveolopment of positional notation is closely tied with the discovery of zero and the development of the Hindu-Arabic numeral system. Positional notation is distinguished from previous notations (such as Roman numerals) for it's use of the same symbol for the different orders of magnitude (for example, the "one's place", "ten's place", "hundred's place"). This greatly simplified arithmetic and lead to the quick spread of the notation across the world.' back
Sam Bowker, Friday essay: the Australian Mosque, 'I presented a slide of an Afghan cameleer’s mosque to a conference of art historians last year, noting that this was Australia’s most distinctive contribution to Islamic architecture. Some of them laughed. It was, after all, little more than a corrugated iron shed, stained and dented, a humble outback structure that serves its purpose and makes no claims to magnificence. Our “Afghan” mosques – made by skilled cameleers and traders from Afghanistan and beyond – are unique to Australia and they are remarkable. But should these 19th and early 20th-century regional buildings define our concept of a typically Australian mosque today?' back
Scott Shane, Richerd Perez-Pena and Aurelien Breeden, 'In-Betweeners" Are Part of a Rich Recruiting Pool for Jihadists, '“When you dig into these cases, you find the ‘why’ is a very complex question,” said Peter Bergen, the director of the security program at New America, a research group, and author of “United States of Jihad.” Personal disappointment, perceptions of discrimination, anger about American foreign policy and the desire “to become a hero in one’s own story” are all at play in addition to jihadist ideology, he said.' back
Sean Thompson, Stan Grant talking about inspiration for his book Talking To My Country after being short-listed for the NIB , 'Mr Grant said he hoped the book would help start conversations and encourage a closer look at what was really happening in Aboriginal communities. “Our history is one of lost opportunity, denial and suffering that we continues to see on a massive scale in this country,” he said.' back
Thomas L. Friedman, Two Ex-Spies and Donald Trump, 'And right now, two of the world’s foremost former spymasters are sending uncoded messages about what it will mean for America and the Western alliance if Donald Trump is elected president. Ladies and gentlemen, I introduce former C.I.A. Director Robert Gates and his longtime nemesis and former K.G.B. agent, President Vladimir Putin of Russia. Putin is voting Trump. Gates is not.' back
Tracy Chevalier, 'Writing is a magic trick that still surprises me when I put pen to paper', 'But what is going on when my pen is scratching, pausing, scratching? I am performing a magic trick that still surprises me. I am in this world, at my desk or kitchen table, but I am simultaneously holding in my head another world full of people I have never physically met but know to their core. That world and those people pour out through my pen: rough – often very rough – but insistent.' back
Writing - Wikipedia, Writing - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia, back

www.naturaltheology.net is maintained by The Theology Company Proprietary Limited ACN 097 887 075 ABN 74 097 887 075 Copyright 2000-2020 © Jeffrey Nicholls