natural theology

We have just published a new website that summarizes the ideas of this site. Available at Cognitive Cosmology.com.

Contact us: Click to email

Notes

Sunday 30 October 2022 - Saturday 5 November 2022

[Notebook: DB 88: Salvation]

[page 178]

Sunday 30 October 2022

The key to peace is recognition of the systems that have evolved to allow a large number of diverse cells to live together consistently to form a living body. Jeffrey Nicholls (2019b): Essay 29: Political dynamics: Rousseau, Rawls and the Physiology of Contract

Bergson has concentrated on space (geometry) completely overlooking that the principal role of human intelligence is [spiritual,] to communicate with one another. Henri Bergson (1911): Creative Evolution

[page 179]

For many people over a long time Christianity has been a source of faith, hope and charity but all of these people have been deceived, as I was, because Christianity is fundamentally built on 3000 year old falsehoods that cannot withstand modern criticism. Reality remains, however, despite the lies told about it and it is the source of ourselves and all our knowledge, hope and love and it is revealed to us by science. Science is constrained by the requirement to measure to break through the illusions of anciently evolved consciousness, but the advent of 'big data' is giving us the statistical power to talk about very complex issues like human feeling which has enormously greater entropy than the subjects of classical physics. The core message of lust for life has to be the recognition that the world is truly divine and it is the stable, reliable and observable source of everything we have and know and can hope for once we tune our behaviour into the nature of the world. Kenan Malik (2022_10_30): TS Eliot’s Waste Land was a barren place. But at least a spirit of optimism still prevailed

Monday 31 October 2022

Finally settling into a groove with lust for life.

Letter to the Rationalist Society: There is no doubt that Christianity is one of the greatest scams perpetrated against the human race. Their core beliefs are bullshit, but this is no reason to deprecate theology and religion as such any more than alchemy and astrology are reasons to deprecate chemistry and astronomy. All the sciences and human knowledge have mythological beginnings because these served as [tacit] foundations for human communication and human society in the early days. We know that mapping between language and reality is completely arbitrary. It is mainly a convention albeit very useful one that we call a foot a foot and there have no doubt been thousands of other names for the same appendage over the 300 000 year history of Homo sapiens. The task now is not to rubbish theology and religion but to reform them on the basis of modern science, politics and ethics. Michael Polanyi (1966, 2009): The Tacit Dimension

Tuesday 1 November
Wednesday 2 November 2022

Edit impossible God and send to Commonweal.

Hobbes, Leviathan, Introduction McPherson. Thomas Hobbes (1651, 1985): Leviathan: The Matter, Forme and Power of a Commonwealth Ecclesiasticall and Civil

page 10: "Hobbes thought of his system of politics as a science.'

[page 180]

Hobbes page 11: Hobbes translated Thucydides 'attracted by his down-to-earth view that men could learn from history "how to bear themselves prudently in the present and providentially toward the future".' We like to extend history back to the beginning and explore the prudence and providence of evolution. Thucydides - Wikipedia

page 21: Hobbes has 'a commitment to civil peace by whatsoever means and whatever allegiance this was to be obtained.'

page 24: ' . . . Hobbes was a potent influence right through from the seventeenth century to the nineteenth. As soon as he had demonstrated the need for a simple sovereign power, no one, from the Revellers to Harringon to Locke, disputed it. All they disputed was whether it need be a self perpetuating sovereign body.' We would like to think that this sovereign body be guided by theology, ie a scientifically established theory of everything.

page 26: 'civil philosophy is demonstrable because we make commonwealths ourselves.'

page 27: Whosoever looketh into himself and considereth what he doth, when he doth think, opine, reason, hope, feare, etc and upon what grounds; he shall thereby read and know, what are the thoughts and Passions of all other men upon the like occasions. . . . [And] when I shall have set down my own reading orderly and perspicuously, the pains left another, will only be to consider, if he also find not the same in himself. For this kind of Doctrine admitteth of no other Demonstations [assuming human symmetry].

This may be embraced by the notion of survival which embraces an enormous spectrum of emotional states other than that which I see in myself.

page 28: 'Hobbes staked his claim to this reading of human nature. It displeased many. It still does. But we should not reject it out of hand.'

'every man . . . shuns . . . death; and this he doth by a certain impulsion of nature, no less than that whereby a stone moves downward.

page 29: Hobbes believed he had [explained everything]. He believed that the elementary factors he postulated were so self -evident that every honest operator would have to admit them.

Evolution uses means far outside honesty.

page 31: Appetites and aversions; love and hate, attraction and repulsion. Lucretius. Lucretius - Wikipedia

[page 181]

Hobbes page 34: The powers of men;

Natural Power is the eminence of the Faculties of Body or Mind; as extraordinary Strength, Forme, Prudence, Art, Eloquence, Liberality, Nobility. Instrumentall are those Powers which acquired by these, or by fortune, are means and instruments to acquire more; as Riches, Reputations, Friends and all the secret working of God, which men call Good Luck." And priests call grace.

page 35: ' (5) all acquired power consists in command over some of the powers of other men.'

page 36: '(6) that some men's desires are without limit.' Aquinas II, I. Aquinas, Summa, I II, 2, 8: Does any created good constitute man's happiness?

page 37: 'Man's need for power has now become a necessarily harmful thing.'

' This is the grand conclusion of Hobbes analysis of human nature. He has only to add to it his postulate about men's innate aversion to death and further postulate about men's ability to behave with a clearer view of their own long-run interest than they commonly did, to get his prescription for obedience to an all powerful sovereign.'

We apply this idea to get from cognitive cosmology to human obedience to the nature of the world.

page 38: 'Hobbes was using a mental model corresponding to bourgeoisie market society.' Bourgeoisie - Wikipedia

Thursday 3 November 2022

Hobbes page 38: 'Everyone seeks to transfer some of their powers of other men to himself or to resist the transfer of some of his to the others, and he does not not by open force but by market-like operation which sets each man's value at 'so much as would be given for the use of his Power.' Leviathan 10/42.

McPherson page 39: 'It has been demonstrated elsewhere that the capitalist market model is the only one that fulfils these requirements.'

page 40; 'state of nature' 'what would exist if there was no common power able to restrain individuals, no law and no law-enforcement (L, 13/62).

page 41: '. . . the life of man, solitary, poore, nasty, brutish and short.'

[page 182]

Hobbes page 44: 'Covenants without the Sword are but Words, and of no strength to secure a man at all.' [Contrast to honour society]. Honor killing - Wikipedia

page 45: 'In those nations whose commonwealths have been long-lived andnot destroyed but by foreign warre, the Subjects never did dispute of the Sovereign Power.'

In the human body we see the Sovereign Power formally represented by a common genotype, [the Rule of Law].

A key concept almost absent from US politics and essential to preventing civil war is that the opposition be loyal to the concept of parliamentary government even if they differ on matters of principle.

Friday 4 November 2022
Saturday 5 November 2022

Two interesting Millennium Prize problems P vs NP and Quantum Yang Mills which I would love to express in terms of cognitive cosmology.

P vs NP seems easy. P is Turing computable and so deterministic. NP is not Turing computable and so only accessible by random variations but once the new species which is deterministically sustainable by P processes is discovered it will become a survivor. This may be the foundation for a rewrite of Cognitive Cosmology, page 6: Evolution: genetic memory, variation and selection.

On the other hand the Yang-Mills problem still looks intractable.

Carlson page 131: 'The solution of the problem of massless Yang-Mills fields for the strong interactions has a completely different nature. The solution did not come from adding fields to Yang-Mills theory, but by discovering a remarkable property of Quantum Yang-mills theory itself, that is the quantum theory whole Lagrangian is

L = 1/4g2 Tr F ∧ * F

[whose meaning I have yet to understand]. This property is called "asymptotic freedom" Roughly this means that at short distances, the field displays quantum behaviour very similar tp its classical behaviour, yet at long distances the classical theory is no longer a good guide to the quantum theory of the field. Yang-Mills theory - Wikipedia

[page 183]

My progress so far on this problem is hinted at in Cognitive Cosmology, page 22: Gravitation and quantum theory—in the beginning.

Carlson page 131: 'Asymptotic freedom, together with other theoretical and experimental discoveries made in the 1960s and 1970s made it possible to describe the nuclear force by a non-abelian gauge theory with the gauge group G = SU(3). The additional fields described at the classical level, "quarks" are spin 1/2 objects somewhat analogous to the electron., but transforming in the fundamental representation of SU(3). The non-abelian gauge theory of the strong force is called Quantum Electrodynamics (QCD).'

'But classical non-abelian gauge theory is very different from the observed world of strong interaction; for QCD to describe the strong force successfully it must have at the quantum level the following three properties, each of which is dramatically different from the behaviour of the classical theory:

(1) mass gap; Constant Δ > 0 such that every excitation of the vacuum has energy of at least Δ.

(2) "quark confinement".

(3) Chiral symmetry breaking.

My basic idea is that the principle of symmetry with respect to complexity (based on Cantor's theorem) may show that a proton is formally identical to the universe which is full of massive particles which are asymptotically free in that all move inertially but their only escape is down a black hole into nothingness [in other words, the proton and the universe are duals of one another].

The cognitive essence of the idea is that Minkowski space is ipso facto logically consistent with quantum theory through its metric and enables asymptotically free inertial motion (see Cognitive Cosmology, page 12: The quantum creation of Minkowski space). Confinement is established by contradiction. contradictory states (like existing outside the universe) simply do not and cannot exist just as Socrates cannot simultaneously sit and stand.

I do think I know something, but is it true? If it is do I have a

[page 184]

duty to go public? How can I do this? I am still working on the principle that if I can make my story good enough it will spread itself. Alternatively, if I make is good enough to convince myself, I will be motivate to become an activist of some wort and it is very difficult to find a place to engage in the current confused world of ideology.

Copyright:

You may copy this material freely provided only that you quote fairly and provide a link (or reference) to your source.

Further reading

Books

Hobbes (1651, 1985), Thomas, Leviathan: The Matter, Forme and Power of a Commonwealth Ecclesiasticall and Civil, Penguin Classics 1985 ' Written during the turmoil of the English Civil War, Leviathan is an ambitious and highly original work of political philosophy. Claiming that man's essential nature is competitive and selfish, Hobbes formulates the case for a powerful sovereign—or "Leviathan"—to enforce peace and the law, substituting security for the anarchic freedom he believed human beings would otherwise experience. This worldview shocked many of Hobbes's contemporaries, and his work was publicly burnt for sedition and blasphemy when it was first published. But in his rejection of Aristotle's view of man as a naturally social being, and in his painstaking analysis of the ways in which society can and should function, Hobbes opened up a whole new world of political science. Based on the original 1651 text, this edition incorporates Hobbes's own corrections, while also retaining the original spelling and punctuation, to read with vividness and clarity. C. B. Macpherson's introduction elucidates one of the most fascinating works of modern philosophy for the general reader.' 
Amazon
  back

Polanyi (1966, 2009), Michael, and Amaryta Sen (foreword), The Tacit Dimension, University Of Chicago Press 1966, 2009 ' “I shall reconsider human knowledge by starting from the fact that we can know more than we can tell,” writes Michael Polanyi, whose work paved the way for the likes of Thomas Kuhn and Karl Popper. The Tacit Dimension argues that tacit knowledge—tradition, inherited practices, implied values, and prejudgments—is a crucial part of scientific knowledge. Back in print for a new generation of students and scholars, this volume challenges the assumption that skepticism, rather than established belief, lies at the heart of scientific discovery.' 
Amazon
  back

Links

Aatish Taseer, In Search of a Lost Spain, ' ON A MORNING of haunting heat in Seville, I sought out the tomb of Ferdinand III. There, in the Gothic cool, older Spaniards came and went, dropping to one knee and crossing themselves before the sepulcher of the Castilian monarch. There were men in staid tucked-in shirts, gray checked with yellow, and women with short-cropped hair and knee-length dresses, slim belts around their waists. They sat in pews under a coffered ceiling, dourly communing with El Santo, the patron saint of what would come to be called La Reconquista — the man under whom five and a half centuries of Muslim rule had in 1248 come to an end in this town: Seville, or Ishbiliya, as it was known then./ back

Aquinas, Summa, I II, 2, 8, Does any created good constitute man's happiness?, 'I answer that, It is impossible for any created good to constitute man's happiness. For happiness is the perfect good, which lulls the appetite altogether; else it would not be the last end, if something yet remained to be desired. Now the object of the will, i.e. of man's appetite, is the universal good; just as the object of the intellect is the universal true. Hence it is evident that naught can lull man's will, save the universal good. This is to be found, not in any creature, but in God alone; because every creature has goodness by participation. Wherefore God alone can satisfy the will of man, according to the words of Psalm 102:5: "Who satisfieth thy desire with good things." Therefore God alone constitutes man's happiness.' back

Bourgeoisie - Wikipedia, Bourgeoisie - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia, ' The bourgeoisie is a sociologically defined social class, equivalent to the middle or upper middle class. They are distinguished from, and traditionally contrasted with, the proletariat by their affluence, and their great cultural and financial capital. . . . The bourgeoisie in its original sense is intimately linked to the existence of cities, recognized as such by their urban charters (e.g., municipal charters, town privileges, German town law), so there was no bourgeoisie apart from the citizenry of the cities. . . . In Marxist philosophy, the bourgeoisie is the social class that came to own the means of production during modern industrialization and whose societal concerns are the value of property and the preservation of capital to ensure the perpetuation of their economic supremacy in society.' back

Foo, Arabaci, Zych & Mann, Quantum Signatures of Black Hole Mass Superpositions, 'Abstract We present a new operational framework for studying “superpositions of spacetimes,” which are of fundamental interest in the development of a theory of quantum gravity. Our approach capitalizes on nonlocal correlations in curved spacetime quantum field theory, allowing us to formulate a metric for spacetime superpositions as well as characterizing the coupling of particle detectors to a quantum field. We apply our approach to analyze the dynamics of a detector (using the Unruh-deWitt model) in a spacetime generated by a Banados-Teitelboim-Zanelli black hole in a superposition of masses. We find that the detector exhibits signatures of quantum-gravitational effects corroborating and extending Bekenstein’s seminal conjecture concerning the quantized mass spectrum of black holes in quantum gravity. Crucially, this result follows directly from our approach, without any additional assumptions about the black hole mass properties.' back

Henri Bergson (1911), Creative Evolution, Citation: Henri Bergson. "Table of Contents", Creative Evolution, translated by Arthur Mitchell, Ph.D. New York: Henry Holt and Company (1911).
Editors' Note: The jacket of a recent republication of this book described it as "the fullest expression of the philosopher's ideas about the problem of existence, propounding a theory of evolution completely distinct from those of earlier thinkers and scientists".' back

Honor killing - Wikipedia, Honor killing - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia, ' An honor killing (American English), honour killing (Commonwealth English), or shame killing[1] is the murder of an individual, either an outsider or a member of a family, by someone seeking to protect what they see as the dignity and honor of themselves or their family. Honor killings are often connected to religion, caste and other forms of hierarchical social stratification, or to sexuality. Most often, it involves the murder of a woman or girl by male family members, due to the perpetrators' belief that the victim has brought dishonor or shame upon the family name, reputation or prestige.' back

Jeffrey Nicholls (2019b), Essay 29: Political dynamics: Rousseau, Rawls and the Physiology of Contract, ' In this essay I wish to briefly examine the provisions made by Rousseau and Rawls for dealing with contractual problems and then to examine the overall problem in the light of the physiology of multicellular creatures. A mammal is a stable self reproducing system comprising of many trillions of individual cells which is continually assailed by millions of species of freeloading parasites, ranging from cells turned cancerous through viruses and bacteria to large carnivores. In broad terms we are dealing with cooperation and immunity, and I hope to throw some light on the immunity of the social systems envisaged by Rousseau, and Rawls. back

Jessica Genauer, A struggle between normality and madness: why Volodymyr Zelensky’s speeches have captured the world’s attention, ' Since Russia invaded Ukraine on February 24, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky has captured the world’s attention with powerful speeches broadcast from a besieged Kyiv. His words have galvanised global support for Ukraine’s struggle. Now, a selection of 16 wartime speeches, chosen by Zelensky himself, will be published in a new volume: A Message From Ukraine. All proceeds from book sales will go to United24, an initiative established by him to raise funds for Ukraine. . . . Perhaps, the true power of Zelensky’s speeches lies ultimately in the very ordinariness of his manner and message – reminding us that we all strive for freedom and life, and showing us the power of remaining human even under the most inhuman conditions.' back

Joshua Zeitz , Where Will This Political Violence Lead? Look to the 1850s. , ' The decision of so many American conservatives to embrace political violence, or the language and symbolism of political violence, is a troubling reality. We can’t have a functioning democracy if one side refuses to accept its norms and rules. But history suggests we might have more to worry about. Democratic violence in the 1850s ultimately led a majority of Republicans, who represented the political majority, to draw a line in the sand and enforce it by violence when necessary. If history is a guidepost, we are on the precipice of dangerous future in which politics devolves into a contest of force rather than ideas. That’s a future everyone should want to avoid.' back

Kenan Malik (2022_10_30), TS Eliot’s Waste Land was a barren place. But at least a spirit of optimism still prevailed, ' In an essay on James Joyce’s Ulysses, Eliot portrayed the novel, published in the same year as The Waste Land, as depicting “the immense panorama of futility and anarchy which is contemporary history”. That may be a curdled reading of Joyce, but it is revealing of Eliot’s own preoccupations. Eliot suggests we live in a world that preferred the deadness of cynicism to the fragility of hope Those preoccupations turned The Waste Land, paradoxically, into both the greatest modernist poem and a profound lament for the impact of modernism and for the loss of a moral anchor through the erosion of faith and tradition. The modern world had, for Eliot, become a spiritless, barren wasteland in which people lived disconnected from each other, driven largely by individual lusts and desires: “Here is no water but only rock/ Rock and no water and the sandy road".' back

Lucretius - Wikipedia, Lucretius - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia, 'Titus Lucretius Carus c. 15 October 99 BC – c. 55 BC) was a Roman poet and philosopher. His only known work is the didactic philosophical poem De rerum natura about the tenets and philosophy of Epicureanism, and which is usually translated into English as On the Nature of Things. back

Megan Greenwell, Universal Basic Income Has Been Tested Repeatedly. It Works. Will America Ever Embrace It?, ' If empirical evidence ruled the world, guaranteed income would be available to every poor person in America, and many of those people would no longer be poor. But empirical evidence does not rule the world, and it is far from clear that there is a political path forward for guaranteed income on a large scale.' back

Mick McKenzie, Amerlia Ballinger & Joel Tozer, Trafficked: Women shunted ‘like cattle’ around Australia for sex work, ' A global human trafficking syndicate has exploited flaws in Australian border security and the immigration system that allowed it to run a national illegal sex racket moving exploited foreign women around the country like “cattle”. The crime boss at the operation’s centre set up his Australian operation immediately after his release from jail in Britain, where he was implicated in a similar illegal sex ring. Binjun Xie, now a wealthy Sydney resident but previously identified by UK police as a Chinese triad boss nicknamed “The Hammer”, is one of several crime syndicate figures using migration system gaps.' back

Thucydides - Wikipedia, Thucydides - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia, ' Thucydides (c. 460 – c. 400 BC) was an Athenian historian and general. His History of the Peloponnesian War recounts the fifth-century BC war between Sparta and Athens until the year 411 BC. Thucydides has been dubbed the father of "scientific history" by those who accept his claims to have applied strict standards of impartiality and evidence-gathering and analysis of cause and effect, without reference to intervention by the gods, as outlined in his introduction to his work.' back

Yang-Mills theory - Wikipedia, Yang-Mills theory - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia, 'Yang–Mills theory is a gauge theory based on the SU(N) group, or more generally any compact, reductive Lie algebra. Yang–Mills theory seeks to describe the behavior of elementary particles using these non-Abelian Lie groups and is at the core of the unification of the electromagnetic force and weak forces (i.e. U(1) × SU(2)) as well as quantum chromodynamics, the theory of the strong force (based on SU(3)). Thus it forms the basis of our understanding of the Standard Model of particle physics.' back

www.naturaltheology.net is maintained by The Theology Company Proprietary Limited ACN 097 887 075 ABN 74 097 887 075 Copyright 2000-2022 © Jeffrey Nicholls