Natural Theology

We have just published a new website that develops the ideas of this site. Available at Cognitive Cosmology.com.

Contact us: Click to email

Notes

Sunday 13 August 2023 - Saturday 19 August 2023

[page 197]

Sunday 13 August 2023

Preface: Every particle has a soul: Hilbert's angels

Introduction: The World is divine

Chapter 1: The god of Aristotle, Aquinas and the Catholic Church.

New book: the world is sacred.

We are looking for a universal scientific angle that cuts across all cultures. Perhaps one way is to go back to indigenous history. Deeper to emphasize that we are all one species that can reproductively love one another.

World peace requires a common enemy which is our theology and lifestyle based on an outside benevolent father who will save us from our stupidity. So we work from human unity to initial singularity and back,

What do I want: to unite theology and physics in a significant theoretical picture. The basic problem is to unite our individual perceptions of our own realities with the reality of the world we live in.

[page 198]

Many religious traditions ignore the necessity for survival by maintaining that we are fatally damaged aliens in a strange world destined for an eternal home elsewhere, ie the Catholic Church says we do not belong here, the Fall is the massive lie at the root of the Catholic Church because I know that it is fundamentally wrong. Catholic rape myths Burgin. The best way for me to deal witg the church is to make it personal, to cast myself as a centre of nucleation for a new universal view of theology. Basically to counter the Church's belief that I am a stranger in a strange land, my mind perverted since childhood by Catholic doctrine. Rachael Burgin (2023_08_12): Rape myths make it almost impossible for victim-survivors of sexual assault to find justice in Australia’s legal system

I am finding it very hard to sort myself out, like being in the woodheap again.

Monday 14 August 2023

A Royal Affair Nikolaj Arcel (Director): A Royal Affair

Tuesday 15 August 2023

Eaton et al Eaton, Kim, deBruyn, Moyi & Reneau (14 August 2023): Exclusive: How a Rare Portrait of an Enslaved Child Arrived at the Met

In trouble now with the book 06_trinity_transfinity. Previously I was making Hibert space kinematic, now I am flirting with dynamic, but perhaps losing the gravity assist.

[page 199]

Maybe back to ideal Hilbert space like cognitive cosmology, Keep trying. What I need here is a big bit of success to cheer me on. I feel as though I am mostly a failure, although I do not like writing this. Success came easy when I was young but * then I was forced to take on the Catholic Church and things have been going down ever since, I am always looking for the big theoretical breakthrough that slays the Church in its tracks, but it is like Trump, so full of lies that it is impregnable, but I must go on. Part of my trouble is that none of my little successes are good enough for me. So I have to get more creative. I keep reminding myself that I am playing a long game and have 20 years to go. I also have to remember that I have spent about $100 000 trying to find a partner to carry me through this task and have thus learnt at great expense that this is a hopeless task so now I have to retreat into my shell, work hard and recover my fortune.*

Although I regularly write about how bad things are, as the passage between the asterisks above, I sort of don't mean it because I feel very confident that I will prevail. Lonergan Wikipedia: 'one key to Lonergan's project is self-appropriation, that is the personal discovery and personal embrace of the dynamic structure of inquiry, insight, judgement and decision.' Bernard Lonergan - Wikipedia

[page 200]

Something I secretly and arrogantly enjoy about myself is the feeling that I know a lot more about theology that Lonergan, who is hung up on the [Catholic] transcendental and spiritual, and a lot more quantum physics that Einstein, who is hung up on general covariance rather than the idea that communication changes both participants. I have to realize that inside god, like inside my mind, is a universe. Meanwhile, of course, I have not made a ripple in the wider intellectual world. Now I am feeling better already. For some reason, perhaps because everything seems too easy for me and people usually seem to think well of me, I value my failures more than my successes. I am an engineer, leaning from a history of failure. General covariance - Wikipedia, Henry Petroski (2006): Success Through Failure: The Paradox of Design

Wednesday 16 August 2023

So my dream has always been a Nobel Prize for physics, one for theology and a theory that wipes out the Catholic Church, but I should just relax and be a happy old bloke who passed through life without causing a ripple. Results will come if they come. Always hunting in the dark and have been pleased with the insights that have come to me over the last 60 years since I began theology. Even though I still have not got a complete picture, I am hoping that it will come. These notes contain almost everything I have ever thought so they are a public record that may help other people along.

[page 201]

My problem is to replace the syllabus of fictions in Catholicism with scientifically reliable truth. What is the next step after the quantum initial singularity with its omnipotence. Each idea of the syllabus should be completed with the denouement predicted by cognitive cosmogenesis. Pope Pius X: Lamentabili Sane: The Syllabus of Errors (Condemning the Errors of the Modernists) Sacred Congregation of the Holy Office, July 3, 1907

Why don't I believe myself? Or am I just destructively testing my beliefs?

Seven arts: Film, architecture, sculpture, painting, music, poetry and dance. Darren Paul Fisher. Darren Paul Fisher: What is it about the books of Terry Pratchett that make them so difficult to adapt to the screen?

We think of a musical instrument as a space and the most musical space in mathematics is Hilbert space. So the first thing we want the initial singularity to do is create space, Hilbert space.

What I need is to have the courage to go ahead with the book even if I am not 100% certain.

Thursday 17 August 2023

Einstein on Newton: Newton sought deterministic computation of positions of elements of the solar system given initial positions: he wanted to fulfill Laplace's dream of determinism which was also Einstein's. Laplace's demon - Wikipedia

New Ansatz: gravitation before quantum mechanics. Einstein page 39: Who would presume today to decide the question whether the law of

[page 202]

causation and the differential law, these ultimate premises of the Newtonian view of nature, must definitely be given up? Albert Einstein (2009): Einstein's Essays in Science

We must replace these premises with logic and the quantum of action.

Tycho epitaph: "He lived like a sage and died like a fool."

Hilbert space and rainbows.

Whiston: "Newton was of the most fearful, cautious and suspicious temper that I ever knew." J J O'Connor & E F Robertson: MacTutor: Isaac Newton

Einstein page 58: 'In the general theory of relativity the doctrine of space and time, or kinematics, no longer figured as a fundamental independent of the rest of physics. The geometrical behaviour of bodies and the motion of clocks rather depend on the gravitational fields which, in their turn are produced by matter' or is matter produced by energy in the gravitational fields? [, or is the kinematics of Minkowski space produced by quantum mechanics thus establishing gravitation and the dynamics of matter and energy? - a question of carts and horses].

' The new theory of gravitation diverges, considerably, as regards principles, from Newton's theory. But its practical results agree so nearly with those of Newton's theory that it is difficult to find criteria for distinguishing them that are accessible to experience.' Joseph H. Taylor (1994): Binary Pulsars and Relativistic Gravity

page 59: 'The chief attraction of the theory

[page 203]

lies in its logical completeness. If a single one of the conclusions drawn from it proves wrong, it must be given up. To modify it without destroying the whole structure seems impossible.

Friday 18 August 2023

Making a lot of headway on cognitive cosmogenesis, gravitation from Aristotle to Einstein.

What I need to make headway is a moral case for the divine universe but I am still bogged in the technical detail of joining physics and theology and dealing with the dichotomy between matter and spirit which denigrates matter and material concerns. I am looking for the light right down with quantum mechanics and gravitation and the cognitive foundations of the universe which have, it appears, no roots in gravitation because a continuum carries no information.

Quantum mechanics → Minkowski space → general relativity

Saturday 19 August 2023

Still trying to understand the role of gravitation at the initial singularity. Is it identical to god, omnipotent and ignorant?

[page 204]

Would this be wonderful if we could feel god as they teach us to walk?

So we see gravitation as the continuous element of the initial singularity that controls the kinematic and dynamic operation of quantum mechanics to create the universe within it. At present chapter 3 is gravitation but we cannot make the general theory without the special theory so we make chapter 3 quantum mechanics and take it as far as the kinematic creation of Minkowski space and then chapter 4 which uses gravitation to add massive energetic particles to the world by the zero energy hypothesis.

Einstein page 84: [Finally found the source of favourite Einstein quote used in the essay on the divinity of money to create a model of the psychological "Hilbert Oscillator"]:

But the years of anxious searching in the dark, with their intense longing, their alternations of confidence and exhaustion, and the final emergence into the light;—only those who have experienced it can understand that. Einstein (2009) page 78: Notes on the Origin of the General Theory of Relativity.
Jeffrey Nicholls (1992): An essay on the divinity of money

Copyright:

You may copy this material freely provided only that you quote fairly and provide a link (or reference) to your source.

Further reading

Books

Einstein (2009), Albert, and Translated by Alan Harris, Einstein's Essays in Science, Philosophical Library / Dover 1934, 2009 'His name is synonymous with "genius," but these essays by the renowned physicist and scholar are accessible to any reader. In addition to outlining the core of relativity theory in everyday language, Albert Einstein presents fascinating discussions of other scientific fields to which he made significant contributions. The Nobel Laureate also profiles some of history's most influential physicists, upon whose studies his own work was based. Assembled during Einstein's lifetime from his speeches and essays, this book marks the first presentation to the wider world of the scientist's accomplishments in the field of abstract physics. Along with relativity theory, these articles examine the methods of theoretical physics, principles of research, and the concept of scientific truth. Einstein's speeches to audiences at Columbia University and the Prussian Academy of Science appear here, along with his insightful observations on such giants of science as Johannes Kepler, Sir Isaac Newton, James Clerk Maxwell, Niels Bohr, Max Planck, and others.' 
Amazon
  back

Petroski (2006), Henry, Success Through Failure: The Paradox of Design, Princeton University Press 2006 Amazon editorial review: 'Civil engineer and historian Petroski interprets the 1940 collapse of the Tacoma Narrows Bridge as a cautionary tale for designers. That bridge failed because engineers made it by enlarging a previously successful idea. Wise designers, Petroski insists, must always contemplate the possibility of failure. Indeed, it is usually failure that spurs designers on toward improved blueprints. Failure-induced improvement may mean merely that lecturers can use a laser pointer in place of a yardstick, but it may also mean that physicians can turn to lifesaving diagnostic software far superior to fallible human protocols. The potential for failure manifests itself before the event to those designers blessed with prescience, but often improvements are only implemented in the wake of actual failures. From ancient Roman engineers dismayed at the failure of stone-arch bridges to twenty-first-century American architects stunned by the collapse of the Twin Towers, designers have frequently learned valuable principles through hard tutelage. Lucid and concise, this study invites nonspecialists to share in the challenge of trial-and-error engineering.' Bryce Christensen Copyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved  
Amazon
  back

Links

Bernard Lonergan - Wikipedia, Bernard Lonergan - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia, ' Bernard Joseph Francis Lonergan SJ CC (17 December 1904 – 26 November 1984) was a Canadian Jesuit priest, philosopher, and theologian, regarded by many as one of the most important thinkers of the 20th century. Lonergan's works include Insight: A Study of Human Understanding (1957) and Method in Theology (1972), as well as two studies of Thomas Aquinas, several theological textbooks, and numerous essays, including two posthumously published essays on macroeconomics. A projected 25-volume Collected Works is underway with the University of Toronto Press. He held appointments at the Pontifical Gregorian University, Regis College, Toronto, as Distinguished Visiting Professor at Boston College, and as Stillman Professor of Divinity at Harvard University.' back

Darren Paul Fisher, What is it about the books of Terry Pratchett that make them so difficult to adapt to the screen?, ' When you delve into the world of literature, few names shine as brightly as Terry Pratchett’s. Despite his early death, the prolific British author continues to enchant readers with his Discworld book series, a fantasy universe that satirises our own with clever wit and insightful humour. His social commentary is so astute, in fact, that his fictional measure that truly measured the nuances of financial inequality has recently been taken up by a real anti-poverty campaign in the United Kingdom. In short, he is one of the greatest novelists of all time.' back

Eaton, Kim, deBruyn, Moyi & Reneau (14 August 2023), Exclusive: How a Rare Portrait of an Enslaved Child Arrived at the Met, ' The Met recently acquired “Bélizaire and the Frey Children,” a 19th-century Louisiana portrait with a secret: For over a 100 years, the image of an enslaved child was erased. This is his story.' back

General covariance - Wikipedia, General covariance - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia, In theoretical physics, general covariance (also known as diffeomorphism covariance or general invariance) is the invariance of the form of physical laws under arbitrary differentiable coordinate transformations. The essential idea is that coordinates do not exist a priori in nature, but are only artifices used in describing nature, and hence should play no role in the formulation of fundamental physical laws.' back

Ibrahim Al-Marashi, Blackwater paved the way for Wagner, ' It is hardly surprising that Putin has decided to preserve a mercenary force that has proven quite effective in pushing forward his foreign policy adventures in Europe, the Middle East and Africa. He has likely learned a lesson or two from another great power – the United States – whose heavy reliance on PMCs paved the way for the growing privatisation and outsourcing of war across the globe. . . . .. The employment of contractors by the US government is not a recent phenomenon, but over the past two decades it has greatly expanded. While in World War II, 10 percent of American armed forces were privately contracted, during the “war on terror”, launched in 2001, they reached some 50 percent, sometimes more. Needing hundreds of thousands of personnel to carry out military operations in Afghanistan, Iraq and elsewhere, but fearing domestic backlash, the US government had to turn to PMCs. Since the start of the “war on terror”, the Pentagon has spent $14 trillion, with one-third to one-half of it going to military contractors in combat zones. A lot of this money has gone to contracts related to logistics, construction and weapons supplies, but a sizable chunk has also paid for “hired guns”. During the height of the 2008 counterinsurgency effort in Iraq, the number of contractors reached 163,400 (including people in non-combat roles) compared to 146,800 US troops. In 2010, amid the “surge” in Afghanistan, when additional troops were deployed for a renewed offensive against the Taliban, there were 112,100 contractors (including people in non-combat roles) compared to 79,100 troops.' back

J J O'Connor & E F Robertson, MacTutor: Isaac Newton, ' Newton's greatest achievement was his work in physics and celestial mechanics, which culminated in the theory of universal gravitation. By 1666 Newton had early versions of his three laws of motion. He had also discovered the law giving the centrifugal force on a body moving uniformly in a circular path. However he did not have a correct understanding of the mechanics of circular motion. Newton's novel idea of 1666 was to imagine that the Earth's gravity influenced the Moon, counter-balancing its centrifugal force. From his law of centrifugal force and Kepler's third law of planetary motion, Newton deduced the inverse-square law.' back

Jeffrey Nicholls (1992), An essay on the divinity of money , ' The rise of science questioned revelation and the churches as sources of truth, but they have remained in existence because science still lacks the power to ask or answer the fundamental questions of life and death that concern theology. Here I outline a new scientific theology whose model of god derives not from ancient text but from the mathematical theory of text and communication itself. I propose that this model describes the universe of our experience, which is therefore fittingly called god. I then interpret this model using elements of current physical theory. These ideas are then applied to money. The movement of money is an abstract representation of the the activity of society as a whole, just as the flow of momentum in space-time is an abstract representation of the physical universe. My hypothesis is that proper understanding and political control of public cashflows is necessary and sufficient to obtain peaceful civilisation.' back

Joseph H. Taylor (1994), Binary Pulsars and Relativistic Gravity, ' At present levels of accuracy, a small kinematic correction (approximately 0.5% of the observed) must be included to account for accelerations of the solar system and the binary pulsar system in the Galactic gravitational field. After doing so, we find that Einstein’s theory passes this extraordinarily stringent test with a fractional accuracy better than 0.4%. The clock-comparison experiment for PSR 1913 + 16 thus provides direct experimental proof that changes in gravity propagate at the speed of light, thereby creating a dissipative mechanism in an orbiting system. It necessarily follows that gravitational radiation exists and has a quadrupolar nature.' back

Kate Selig, Judge rules in favor of Montana youths in landmark climate decision, ' In the first ruling of its kind nationwide, a Montana state court decided Monday in favor of young people who alleged the state violated their right to a “clean and healthful environment” by promoting the use of fossil fuels. The court determined that a provision in the Montana Environmental Policy Act has harmed the state’s environment and the young plaintiffs by preventing Montana from considering the climate impacts of energy projects. The provision is accordingly unconstitutional, the court said. “This is a huge win for Montana, for youth, for democracy and for our climate,” said Julia Olson, the executive director of Our Children’s Trust, which brought the case. “More rulings like this will certainly come.” The sweeping win, one of the strongest decisions on climate change ever issued by a court, could energize the environmental movement and usher in a wave of cases aimed at advancing action on climate change, experts say. The ruling — which invalidates the provision blocking climate considerations — also represents a rare victory for climate activists who have tried to use the courts to push back against government policies and industrial activities they say are harming the planet. . . .. The Montana case will face an appeal to the state Supreme Court, Emily Flower, a spokesperson for Montana Attorney General Austin Knudsen, confirmed Monday. She decried the ruling as “absurd” and said Montanans cannot be blamed for changing the climate.' back

Laplace's demon - Wikipedia, Laplace's demon - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia, ' We may regard the present state of the universe as the effect of its past and the cause of its future. An intellect which at a certain moment would know all forces that set nature in motion, and all positions of all items of which nature is composed, if this intellect were also vast enough to submit these data to analysis, it would embrace in a single formula the movements of the greatest bodies of the universe and those of the tiniest atom; for such an intellect nothing would be uncertain and the future just like the past would be present before its eyes.' A Philosophical Essay on Probabilities, Essai philosophique dur les probabilites introduction to the second edition of Theorie analytique des probabilites based on a lecture given in 1794. back

Nikolaj Arcel (Director), A Royal Affair, 'A young queen (Oscar winner Alicia Vikander), who is married to an insane king, falls secretly in love with her physician (Mads Mikkelsen) — and together they start a revolution that changes the nation [Denmark] forever.' back

Paul Moses, Rudy's RICO Comeuppance, After being sentenced to one hundred years in prison for his racketeering conviction as head of the Genovese organized crime family, Anthony Salerno penned a letter to a newspaper columnist who had expressed alarm about the powerful law that prosecutor Rudy Giuliani had used in the case. “Roy Cohn, my former attorney, always stated that you were an honorable man,” Salerno wrote to columnist Murray Kempton in 1987. Kempton, a Pulitzer Prize winner who’d battled the likes of Cohn during the McCarthy era, had written a column headlined “If RICO Wins, We Lose,” noting various ways the Racketeer Influenced and Corruption Organization Act (RICO) of 1970 let prosecutors circumvent traditional civil-liberties protections. “It is a plaything for frustrated drama actors such as U.S. Attorney Giuliani,” Salerno wrote. “History repeatedly shows us that a government that relies on unprincipled abuses of authority and dubious laws has a tendency to snowball into worse scenarios.” In other words: What goes around, comes around. back

Pope Pius X, Lamentabili Sane: The Syllabus of Errors (Condemning the Errors of the Modernists) Sacred Congregation of the Holy Office, July 3, 1907, 'WITH TRULY LAMENTABLE RESULTS, our age, casting aside all restraint in its search for the ultimate causes of things, frequently pursues novelties so ardently that it rejects the legacy of the human race. Thus it falls into very serious errors, which are even more serious when they concern sacred authority, the interpretation of Sacred Scripture, and the principal mysteries of Faith. The fact that many Catholic writers also go beyond the limits determined by the Fathers and the Church herself is extremely regrettable. In the name of higher knowledge and historical research, (they say), they are looking for that progress of dogmas which is, in reality, nothing but the corruption of dogmas. ... ' back

Rachael Burgin (2023_08_12), Rape myths make it almost impossible for victim-survivors of sexual assault to find justice in Australia’s legal system, This week the public was finally provided with a copy of Walter Sofronoff’s inquiry into the conduct of Bruce Lehrmann’s rape trial. Its release, however, has brought with it more misreporting around sexual violence, including the perpetuation of “rape myths”. A central finding of the inquiry – that the prosecution against Lehrmann was properly brought by the director of public prosecutions, Shane Drumgold SC, who moved to charge Lehrmann after ACT police declined to – has been overlooked in much of the reporting. The inquiry’s findings do not establish Lehrmann’s guilt or innocence, just that the police and the DPP acted appropriately in bringing charges. . . .. The inquiry, and much of the media reporting on it, have consistently erased the voices and experiences of victim-survivors of sexual violence. . . .. What we have learned from the inquiry is that, as it stands, we can’t look to the criminal justice system for answers. As Dame Vera Baird famously said as the victims’ commissioner for England and Wales – we are witnessing the decriminalisation of rape. .. . ..' Dr Rachael Burgin is a senior lecturer in criminal justice at Swinburne Law School and the CEO of Rape and Sexual Assault Research and Advocacy (RASARA) back

SCMP Evident Image of the Year, SCMP Evident Image of the Year, ' The winners of the Evident Image of the Year Award 2022 have been announced. The global winning image was taken by Laurent Formery of the United States.' back

Suzanne Smith (ABC Compass), Hidden children, ' Brendan has discovered that globally there are thousands of children of priests, just like him, who as adults found their biological parents through DNA testing and social media groups. There are 450,000 Catholic priests around the world and, though there are no accurate records, it is estimated that they have fathered over 20,000 children. Crucially, a 25-year study of 1,500 Catholic priests found less than half the priests in the United States attempt celibacy — which experts say is a major factor fuelling so-called reproductive abuse. The study’s author, ex-priest Richard Sipe, argued it creates a culture of secrecy that tolerates and even protects paedophiles — though he estimated that four times as many priests involve themselves sexually with women than with children.' back

www.naturaltheology.net is maintained by The Theology Company Proprietary Limited ACN 097 887 075 ABN 74 097 887 075 Copyright 2000-2023 © Jeffrey Nicholls