Natural Theology

We have just published a new website that develops the ideas of this site. Available at Cognitive Cosmology.com.

Contact us: Click to email

Notes DB 91: Divine_Gravitation_2024

Sunday 4 August 2024 - Saturday 10 Auguast 2024

Sunday 4 August 2024

[page 64]

A usual morning crisis of confidence. Can I justify the sequence of creation of the Universe listed at the beginning of Friday 2 August? It's worth a try. This makes me feel better; agenda feels good, just have to have the confidence to execute it. Meanwhile, somewhere in the middle of the night I thought of a new line of approach which is reluctant to reappear, but one that is giving weight to the notion that the first overtone of a vibrating string causes a fixed point in the middle of the string which provides a root for the timing explanation of fermions and bosons hinted at on Thursday 1 August. Bank balance 510.26

Confidence grows with every little insight as they all coalesce to create a structure. How many evolutionary insights did it take to create an animal like me, beginning way back there with the bifurcation of naked gravitation into potential and

[page 65]

kinetic energy; the discovery of fixed points by quantum mechanics and the bifurcation of particles into fermions and bosons that led to the spacetime which serves to enable the existence of infinite sets of identical particles? This paragraph seems to me to provide a rock solid base upon which to build my church, ie the genome of global peace, the doctrine of reality.

One of the most difficult things about quantum mechanics is to understand life in a formal world where there is no space and time. This is analogous to Einstein's explanation of why it took him ten years to develop general relativity. He had to realize that coordinates have no immediate metrical meaning. At the end of his paper on the field equations of gravitation he writes: ' The postulate of relativity in its most general form . . . makes space-time coordinates physically meaningless parameters'. This is the heart of quantum mechanics. Albert Einstein (1915): The Field Equations of Gravitation

Preface to paper on QFT: 'Quantum mechanics makes space=time coordinates into physically meaningless parameters' [ is this the link we are looking for between relativity and quantum mechanics, starting with naked gravitation?].

Put two fermions in a Hilbert space and their amplitudes will add up to zero.

Include Principles in Alternative_QFT - nothing comes from nothing → eternity. Creation of the world → omnipotence.

[page 66]

Revised cc05_gods_ideas, cc06_evolution

Monday 5 August 2024

The creed gives a concise account, running from creation until the end of time and the life to come, but makes no mention of the central message delivered by Jesus the Son of God and encapsulated in the parable of the Good Samaritan, love your god, love your neighbour (Luke 10:25–37).

The Creed places Christianity in the cosmic context of an empire, represented by Constantine, whose Emperors, beginning with Augustus, presented themselves as gods to strengthen the legitimacy of their imperium.

Lonergan defines metaphysics as an heuristic structure. Since the initial singularity has no structure at all, it is only constrained, like god, by consistency, and so it is in effect transcendental. This, given the nature of the singularity, is [proof that the Universe is divine].

Tuesday 6 August 2024

Alternative_QFT: 6. The emergence of quantum mechanics and the eigenvalue equation - here again we emphasize the intelligence of quantum mechanics in cognitive cosmogenesis. Christopher Shields (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy b): Christopher Shields (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy b)

[page 67]

Revised: cc07_ntwork_brain, cc08_trinity, cc09_create_hilbert, cc10_quantum_emerge, cc11_communication.

Wednesday 7 August 2024

[revised] cc12_hilbert_minkowski, cc13_independence, cc14_measurement.

The key to the creation of Minkowski space, as I first conceive it continues to look good after a few ups and downs, and it lies in the null geodesic followed by massless particles acting as a branch of Hilbert space stretching into Minkowski space and enabling the transfer of energy between fermions [by photons] travelling at the speed of light. The question is why are some things massive and some not and the evolutionary paradigm suggests that there has got to be a selective advantage there. The advantage seems to be the idea that I got from the Shield of the Trinity that the only way for identical divine persons to be discrete is to be at different points in space like fermions, so the discovery of fermions and space, another zero sum differentiation, enables the multiplication of individual fermions which is an advantage in the sense that it has made the Universe and the consequent massive increase in entropy possible. So space/mass seems to be the principle of individuation that converts specifically identical angels into discrete beings just as Aristotle does with forms. Massless photons, on the other hand are distinguished by frequency like the orthogonal basis states of Hilbert space

[page 68]

and those with identical frequency can enter into the same state. I need to know more quantum mechanics here that is probably available in Feynman and Weinberg.

Thursday 8 August 2024

Revised: cc15_invisibility.

Can we see time? Is it an inevitable feature of divinity like gravitation?

Massless particles cannot stop and are in a region without space and time before the advent of 3D space and they maintain that quality when massive particles appear. So photons 'decay' into electrons and positrons with both charge and magnetism. Richard Feynman & Steven Weinberg (1986): Elementary Particles and the Laws of Physics: The 1986 Dirac Memorial Lectures

How do we make an electron and a positron out of a photon? [look at Dirac equation again, the creator of spacetime created by taking the 3D spacetime out of the Schrödinger equation]

Feynman and Weinberg (1986); ref notes23m09d17 etc.

F & W page 2: 'the crucial and necessary idea to wed quantum mechanics and relativity together was the existence of antiparticles. . . . Working along these lines will permit us to explain another of the grand mysteries of the world, namely the Pauli exclusion principle.

[page 69]

F & W page 3: Here the existence of particles and antiparticle permits us to ask a very simple question: if I make two pairs of electrons and positrons and I compare the amplitudes for which they annihilate directly or for when they exchange before they annihilate, why is there a minus sign? ie what is the physics that causes the mathematics?

Count Basie SBS: Music music music. Don't let anything stop you if that's what you want to be. Count Basie: Through His Own Eyes

Feynman page 4: 'In ordinary non-relativistc quantum mechanics if you have a disturbing potential U [ie a message] acting on a particle which is initially in a state of φ0 then the state will be different after the disturbance'. Dirac would write ⟨χ|U|φ0

page 5: U1 at t1, U2 at t2,what is the amplitude for U2 to restore φ0?

Weinberg page 76: 'conservation of charge [is an internal symmetry] which physicists usually call gauge invariance.

Friday 9 August 2024

Do Feynman and Weinberg occupy a QFT echo chamber which could be usefully questions by a theological approach as I propose?

Having a rest and dealing with potential homelessness

[page 70]

and gaining confidence. Both the Feynman and Weinberg Dirac memorial lectures made me feel that quantum field theory is on the wrong track and the killer problem, represented by the outrageous wrongness of the computed cosmological constant seems to be the key to this, particularly since no one seems to really worry about it. The idea that uncertainty (ie limited resolution of action) cause energy makes no sense to me but it seems to pop up everywhere. I like the zero-sum bifurcation of gravitation so much more so I press ahead with cognitive cosmology and its various children by cognitive cosmogenesis. It is so much easier to write when I am a bit inspired, the source of the bible and probably all other durable literature, creating new formal mental species. Cosmological constant problem - Wikipedia

cc15_invisibility done.

Saturday 10 August 2024

cc16_zero-energy done; cc17_gravitation

Linked in: The union of physics and theology demanded by the hypothesis that the Universe is divine demands radical revision to both disciplines. The change to theology is clear: god is no longer an invisible theological being preached by imaginative prophets of every shape. They [god] are the solid reality of ourselves and our world. Physics is closely linked by experiment to the solid reality of

[page 71]

the world, but like the ancient god, the quantum mechanical underpinnings of the world are invisible to us and our attempts to make them visible have led to an extreme distortion through the lens that we use to try to understand what is going on. We divide the world into quantum and classical. We live in the classical world, understand it intuitively, and naturally give it priority but the fact is that quantum mechanics [and gravitation are] the driver of the world. Quantum field theory conceives quantum theory as an accessory to the classical world whereas in fact the classical world is a product of the quantum world. We distort quantum mechanics by tying it to the classical spacetime world. What we must do, to understand quantum theory, is to liberate it from this constraint an set it free of the straightjacket of spacetime which is severely constricted by conservation of energy and momentum which have no meaning in the quantum world that underlies the Minkowski world. There we find pure music, unconstrained by spacetime [and relativity] and so much more interesting and beautiful for this freedom.

An idea for the new preface to cc18_fixed_points. First free ourselves from sin (the old preface) and then free ourselves from spacetime, the new vision which comes to us through music and quantum computation.

Copyright:

You may copy this material freely provided only that you quote fairly and provide a link (or reference) to your source.

Further reading

Books

Baggott (2024), Jim, and John L.Heilbron, Quantum Drama: From the Bohr-Einstein Debate to the Riddle of Entanglement , Oxford UP 2024 ' The definitive account of the great Bohr-Einstein debate and its continuing legacy. In 1927, Niels Bohr and Albert Einstein began a debate about the interpretation and meaning of the new quantum theory. This would become one of the most famous debates in the history of science. At stake were an understanding of the purpose, and defense of the integrity, of science. What (if any) limits should we place on our expectations for what science can tell us about physical reality?Our protagonists slowly disappeared from the vanguard of physics, as its centre of gravity shifted from a war-ravaged Continental Europe to a bold,pragmatic, post-war America. What Einstein and Bohr had considered to be matters of the utmost importance were now set aside. Their debate was regarded either as settled in Bohr's favour or as superfluous to real physics. But the debate was not resolved. The problems of interpretation and meaning persisted, at least in the minds of a few stubborn physicists, such as David Bohm and John Bell, who refused to stop asking awkward questions. The Bohr-Einstein debate was rejoined, now with a new set of protagonists, on a small scale at first. Through their efforts, the debate was revealed to be about physics after all. Their questions did indeed have answers that could be found in a laboratory. As quantum entanglement became a real physical phenomenon, whole new disciplines were established, such as quantum computing, teleportation, and cryptography. The efforts of the experimentalists were rewarded with shares in the 2022 Nobel prize in physics. As Quantum Drama reveals, science owes a large debt to those who kept the discussions going against the apathy and indifference of most physicists before definitive experimental inquiries became possible. Although experiment moved the Bohr-Einstein debate to a new level and drew many into foundational research, it has by no means removed or resolved the fundamental question. There will be no Nobel prize for an answer. That will not shut off discussion. Our Drama will continue beyond our telling of it and is unlikely to reach its final scene before science ceases or the world ends. Quantum mechanics is an extraordinarily successful scientific theory. It is also completely baffling. From the moment of its inception, its founders struggled to understand its meaning. This struggle was most famously encapsulated in the debate between Niels Bohr and Albert Einstein; Quantum Drama tells the story of their engagement and its legacy.' 
Amazon
  back

The Committee for the Compilation of Materials on the Damage Caused by the Atomic Bombs in Hiroshima and Nagasaki, Hiroshima and Nagasaki: The Physical Medical and Social Effects of the Atomic Bombings, Hutchison 1981 Jacket: 'This book is the definitive account of the destruction of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. ... More than four years in the making, this clearly written and jargon free account is both a summary and an analysis by Japan's leading physicists, physicians and social scientists of the full findings about the immediate damage of the bombs ... and their permanent medical, genetic, social and psychological effects. In almost every respect the findings show that the damage caused by the bombs was much more serious than earlier studies have indicated. Not only were there more deaths, but a terrible and lasting impactcan be seen in terms of chronic disease (especially cancers), genetic and chromosomal damage, and social disorganisation - family disruption, crime, suicide and mental illness.' 
Amazon
  back

Links

Albert Einstein (1915), The Field Equations of Gravitation, ' In two recently published papers I have shown how to obtain field equations of gravitation that comply with the postulate of general relativity, i.e., which in their general formulation are covariant under arbitrary substitutions of space-time variables. . . . With this, we have finally completed the general theory of relativity as a logical structure. The postulate of relativity in its most general formulation (which makes space-time coordinates into physically meaningless parameters) leads with compelling necessity to a very specific theory of gravitation that also explains the movement of the perihelion of Mercury. However, the postulate of general relativity cannot reveal to us anything new and different about the essence of the various processes in nature than what the special theory of relativity taught us already. The opinions I recently voiced here in this regard have been in error. Every physical theory that complies with the special theory of relativity can, by means of the absolute differential calculus, be integrated into the system of general relativity theory-without the latter providing any criteria about the admissibility of such physical theory.' back

Christopher Shields (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy b), The Active Mind of De Anima III 5 , ' After characterizingnous the mind (nous) and its activities in De Animaiii 4, Aristotle takes a surprising turn. In De Anima iii 5, he introduces an obscure and hotly disputed subject: the active mind or active intellect (nous poiêtikos). Controversy surrounds almost every aspect of De Anima iii 5, not least because in it Aristotle characterizes the active mind—a topic mentioned nowhere else in his entire corpus—as ‘separate and unaffected and unmixed, being in its essence actuality’ (chôristos kai apathês kai amigês, tê ousia energeia; DA iii 5, 430a17–18) and then also as ‘deathless and everlasting’ (athanaton kai aidion; DA iii 5, 430a23). This comes as no small surprise to readers of De Anima, because Aristotle had earlier in the same work treated the mind (nous) as but one faculty (dunamis) of the soul (psuchê), and he had contended that the soul as a whole is not separable from the body (DA ii 1, 413a3–5). back

Cosmological constant problem - Wikipedia, Cosmological constant problem - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia, ' In cosmology, the cosmological constant problem or vacuum catastrophe is the disagreement between the observed values of vacuum energy density (the small value of the cosmological constant) and theoretical large value of zero-point energy suggested by quantum field theory. Depending on the Planck energy cutoff and other factors, the discrepancy is as high as 120 orders of magnitude, a state of affairs described by physicists as "the largest discrepancy between theory and experiment in all of science" and "the worst theoretical prediction in the history of physics".' back

Count Basie:, Through His Own Eyes, back

Hiroko Tabuchi, E.P.A. Pulls From the Market a Weedkiller Harmful to Fetuses, 'In a move not seen for almost 40 years, the Environmental Protection Agency on Tuesday issued an emergency order suspending all uses of a weedkiller linked to serious health risks for unborn babies. The herbicide dimethyl tetrachloroterephthalate, also known as DCPA or Dacthal, is used on crops such as broccoli, brussels sprouts, cabbage and onions. Fetuses exposed to it could suffer from low birth weight, impaired brain development, decreased I.Q., and impaired motor skills later in life, the E.P.A. said. . . . Mily Treviño Sauceda, executive director of Alianza Nacional de Campesinas, also known as the National Farmworkers Women’s Alliance, called E.P.A.’s decision “historic.” “We know intimately the harm that pesticides, including dimethyl tetrachloroterephthalate, can inflict on our bodies and communities,” she said in a statement accompanying the E.P.A. news release. “This emergency decision is a great first step that we hope will be in a series of others that are based on listening to farmworkers, protecting our reproductive health, and safeguarding our families.” The chemical has been prohibited for use on crops in the European Union since 2009.' back

Kingsbury, Hennigan & Spencer Cohen (2024_08_06), The Last Survivors Speak. It’s Time to Listen., ' The waiting room of the Red Cross hospital in downtown Hiroshima is always crowded. Nearly every available seat is occupied, often by elderly people waiting for their names to be called. Many of these men and women don’t have typical medical histories, however. They are the surviving victims of the American atomic bomb attack 79 years ago. Not many Americans have Aug. 6 circled on their calendars, but it’s a day that the Japanese can’t forget. Even now, the hospital continues to treat, on average, 180 survivors — known as hibakusha — of the blasts each day. When the United States dropped an atomic weapon on Hiroshima on Aug. 6, 1945, the entire citizenries of both countries were working feverishly to win World War II. For most Americans, the bomb represented a path to victory after nearly four relentless years of battle and a technological advance that would cement the nation as a geopolitical superpower for generations. Our textbooks talk about the world’s first use of a nuclear weapon. Many today in Hiroshima and Nagasaki, where the United States detonated a bomb just three days later, talk about how those horrible events must be the last uses of nuclear weapons. back

Richard Feynman & Steven Weinberg (1986), x, Foreword: John C Taylor: 'Dirac Died in 1984, and St John's College, Cambridge (Dirac's College), very generously endowed an annual lecture to be held at Cambridge University in Dirac's memory. The First two lectures, printed here, are contrasting variations of Dirac's theme of the union of quantum theory and relativity.' back

Seanna Leth & Sheretta T. Butler-Barnes , From Michael Brown to Sonya Massey, a decade of police antiblack violence causes grief, worry and coping for Black parents , ' Overall, these messages are intended to elicit racial and cultural pride, while also encouraging Black youth to be cautious and aware of the ongoing realities of racial violence. In a forthcoming study we have on how Black parents in Missouri talk to their adolescents about race, one mother shared: “Like with the Sonya Massey thing, my daughter saw the video and she was like – ‘but she didn’t do anything wrong.’ That’s usually what happens. Like I told her, she called the police for help and they end up killing her. It happens sometimes because they act like they’re scared of Blacks for some reason. I feel like we are not progressing in America with this racism thing.” While Black parents and their children continue to resist racial discrimination through their everyday practices of care, love and joy, there remains a critical need to invest in the health and well-being of Black communities through structural policy changes in education, health care and local government.' back

www.naturaltheology.net is maintained by The Theology Company Proprietary Limited ACN 097 887 075 ABN 74 097 887 075 Copyright 2000-2024 © Jeffrey Nicholls