natural theology

We have just published a new book that summarizes the ideas of this site. Free at Scientific Theology, or, if you wish to support this project, buy at Scientific Theology: A New Vision of God

Contact us: Click to email

Notes

Sunday 21 August 2022 - Saturday 27 August 2022

[Notebook: DB 88: Salvation]

[page 144]

Sunday 21 August 2022

New week, more rain. Back to the beginning of cognitive cosmology for a revision before I complete cc25_conclusion.

The key to all this (I say again) is symmetry with resect to complexity., the idea that the universe grows and thinks as I do [so that a theory of everything and a theory of me are essentially isomorphic]. I began as

[page 145]

an unthinking embryo constrained by my genome and now I am an old person approaching 80. Throughout this development I have been following the same strategy, building on what I have to make the next step.

To do this freely I need an operator that makes no assumptions about my next step but accepts my present state so that my growth is not unnecessarily constrained. This is logic based on the quantum of action whose logical definition is the operator not which changes some present state ψ into a new state not-ψ = ψ .

The first step in my journey was taken by the Christian God with the procession of the second person of the Trinity, God, but not God the Father. Dogma restricts the Trinity to three persons. In my story there is no limit to the fecundity of the divine action so the Universe is full of Gods as Thales realized, quanta of action. Thales of Miletus - Wikipedia

I have worked from my present state back to the beginning, an absolutely simple source of action, the initial singularity. Now I am on my way forward in time from this [eternal] beginning to my current being and the state of the world in which I find myself. This site deals with essentially the same territory as that covered in the first part of his Summa Theologiae. Hopefully the second and third parts will follow.

Aquinas is my greatest literary love. He produced the best possible interpretation of Christian doctrine in a world where the epitome of science was the work of Aristotle. Aristotle was newly discovered in Christian Europe in Aquinas's time ≈ 1600 years after he died (−322 – + 1260) Recovery of Aristotle - Wikipedia

My starting points for this work are Thomas Aquinas and Bernard Lonergan. I read Lonergan's Insight after three years studying Aquinas as a young monk, still a firm Catholic believer. Lonergan broke the mould. His work is an attempt by a Jesuit priest to bring the Dominican Aquinas into the twentieth century. Fo me he failed. His attempt to produce a new proof for the idea that the world in not God made it very clear to me that any consistent approach to theology must identify God and the worldMy first attempt to express this view led to me expulsion from the Order. Bernard Lonergan (1992); Insight: A Study of Human Understanding, Jeffrey Nicholls (1967): How Universal is the Universe?

Monday 22 August 2022

cc03_action, cc04_theology_tacit [now cc04_theol_paradigm]

theology_tacit: A leading and somewhat tragic figure in this story is Albert Einstein. He once gave his religion as Mosaïsch

[page 146]

He was a genius and a determinist. He contributed heavily to quantum mechanics but he could not accept it. One of his famous dicta is that "God does not play dice". At another time he said "God is subtle but not malicious". His greatest achievement was to formulate the general theory of relativity which has since been shown to be precisely true and given us a global theory. At present the leading problem in physics is to develop a quantum mechanical theory of gravitation but it has resisted all attempts to produce such a theory for [a century or so]. The problem seems to that there is a gigantic gap between determinism and reality. This problem, in terms of Michael Polanyi, is that Einstein and physicists are working in a false tacit dimension. My thesis, expressed in this site is that Christian theology is also working in a false tacit dimension, a deterministic once, which sees that the omnipotent and omniscient god is also a determinist, knowing and controlling every aspect of the universe from beginning to end, My contention on this site is that we cannot reform theology until we reject this divine determinism and recognise that god, the universe, cannot be deterministic so the Church which follows in God's steps cannot also be deterministic so the claim to infallibility is self contradictory and must be rejected. This is the burden of this page, setting the scene for the rest of the site.

What we are talking about is a paradigm change, Kuhn, The Structure of Scientific Revolutions Thomas Kuhn (1996)

Tuesday 23 August 2022

Thomas Kuhn Stanford Encyclopedia. Current anomaly in physics: gravitation [current anomaly in theology infallibility and determinism]. Alexander Bird: Thomas Kuhn

Wednesday 24 August 2022

Marilyn Monroe: "I fell in love with myself. Not as I was but how I was going to be. Michèle Dominici: Becoming Marilyn

I'm not a physicist but an impressionist. I would buy the books. Some I read frequently, made notes, an index of my own. Others I just looked at, read bits and pieces, wondered what they meant.

cc25_conclusion: Fear of God, fear of science, fear of death.

cc05_gods_ideas revised and uploaded.

[page 147]

Thursday 25 August 2022

cc08_evolution: unbounded activity bounded by selection and survival. Quantum mechanically this amounts to the group of eigenvectors of a specific conversation = meeting in the angelic quantum world. The group action is equivalent to insight, ie the movement from one eigenvector to the next or the discovery of an eigenvector [fixed point] common to two systems in conversation, something they can agree on. Eigenvalues and eigenvectors - Wikipedia

I am feeling optimistic about cognitive cosmology. In my greenie days I minimized fun activities like demonstrating and sitting on tripods in the forest and confined myself to detailed examination of environmental impact statement to find the inconsistencies. Now I am revising my 2022 website and I see the same approach at work in a detailed and repetitive examination of the foundations of theology which seems to me to be consistent and informative. Now I must stop to watch the market open [one of my shareholdings in the lithium business has just announced an 800% increase in revenue and their shares have dropped!]

WAVE ≡ GROUP ≡ SURVIVOR: symmetry and symmetry breaking, eg [marking a] snowflake.

Dodgy features of Christianity:

Original sin; the speaking serpent, the introduction of pain in childbirth for women, work and death [all introduced to explain the loss of paradise].
The parting of the Red Sea; the murder at Sinai; the Flood; Sodom and Gomorrah; the torture of Job.
Immaculate conception; Virgin birth; eternal life; apocalypse.
Water into wine.
Resurrection; Ascension; Assumption.
Tongues of fire; the Eucharist.
Pope Francis and Satan; indulgences. Carol Kuruvilla: Pope Francis issues dire warning to followers at Vatican Mass: Satan is real
Infallibility; no priestly role for women; autocracy.
Child sexual abuse; child mental abuse.
Poverty, chastity and obedience.
False marketing; heaven and hell; the power of prayer . . . etc etc etc

But we can all agree that Jesus (and all of us) is both human and divine [we are all children of God, as is every other entity on the Universe].

Friday 26 August 2022

Gn 1:27: And god created mankind in his image; in the image of god he created them; male and female he created them.

[page 148]

cc07_network_brain: Imagination: Our human cosmic superpower.

Networks: symmetry and variety. Are networks intelligent? The internet is roughly the same size a human brain.

Saturday 27 August 2022

Copyright:

You may copy this material freely provided only that you quote fairly and provide a link (or reference) to your source.

Further reading

Books

Kuhn (1996), Thomas S, The Structure of Scientific Revolutions, U of Chicago Press 1962, 1970, 1996 Introduction: 'a new theory, however special its range of application, is seldom just an increment to what is already known. Its assimilation requires the reconstruction of prior theory and the re-evaluation of prior fact, an intrinsically revolutionary process that is seldom completed by a single man, and never overnight.' [p 7]  
Amazon
  back

Lonergan (1992), Bernard J F, Insight: A Study of Human Understanding (Collected Works of Bernard Lonergan : Volume 3), University of Toronto Press 1992 '. . . Bernard Lonergan's masterwork. Its aim is nothing less than insight into insight itself, an understanding of understanding' 
Amazon
  back

Links

Alexander Bird (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy), Thomas Kuhn, ' Thomas Samuel Kuhn (1922–1996) is one of the most influential philosophers of science of the twentieth century, perhaps the most influential. His 1962 book The Structure of Scientific Revolutions is one of the most cited academic books of all time. Kuhn’s contribution to the philosophy of science marked not only a break with several key positivist doctrines, but also inaugurated a new style of philosophy of science that brought it closer to the history of science. His account of the development of science held that science enjoys periods of stable growth punctuated by revisionary revolutions.' back

Brian Welch et al, JWST Imaging of Earendel, the Extremely Magnified Star at Redshift z = 6.2, ' The gravitationally lensed star WHL0137-LS, nicknamed Earendel, was identified with a photometric redshift zphot = 6.2 ± 0.1 based on images taken with the Hubble Space Telescope. Here we present James Webb Space Telescope (JWST ) Near Infrared Camera (NIRCam) images of Earendel in 8 filters spanning 0.8–5.0μm. In these higher resolution images, Earendel remains a single unresolved point source on the lensing critical curve, increasing the lower limit on the lensing magnification to μ > 4000 and restricting the source plane radius further to r < 0.02 pc, or ∼ 4000 AU. These new observations strengthen the conclusion that Earendel is best explained by an individual star or multiple star system. The new imaging also supports the previous photometric redshift estimate, solidifying the interpretation of Earendel as a stellar source within the first billion years of the universe. Fitting stellar spectra to our photometry yields a stellar temperature of Teff ' 13000–16000 K assuming the light is dominated by a single star. The delensed bolometric luminosity in this case ranges from log(L) = 5.8– 6.6 L , which is in the range where one expects luminous blue variable stars. Allowing for two stars with different temperatures can yield better fits to the photometry at the expense of increased free parameters, leading to non-unique well-fitting temperatures of Teff & 20000 K and Teff . 13000 K for the hotter and cooler components, respectively. back

Carol Kuruvilla, Pope Francis issues dire warning to followers at Vatican Mass: Satan is real, ' The pontiff warned his followers to look out for the devil’s temptations. On the same day, he asked forgiveness from victims of sex abuse who were betrayed by pedophile priests.' back

Eigenvalues and eigenvectors - Wikipedia, Eigenvalues and eigenvectors - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia, ' In linear algebra, an eigenvector or characteristic vector of a linear transformation is a nonzero vector that changes at most by a scalar factor when that linear transformation is applied to it. The corresponding eigenvalue, often denoted by λ, is the factor by which the eigenvector is scaled. Geometrically, an eigenvector, corresponding to a real nonzero eigenvalue, points in a direction in which it is stretched by the transformation and the eigenvalue is the factor by which it is stretched. If the eigenvalue is negative, the direction is reversed. Loosely speaking, in a multidimensional vector space, the eigenvector is not rotated.' back

Freda Kreier (2022), Ancient tooth DNA reveals how ‘cold sore’ herpes virus has evolved, 'Ancient DNA extracted from the teeth of humans who lived long ago is yielding new information about pathogens past and present. In one of the latest studies, researchers uncovered and sequenced ancient herpes genomes for the first time, from the teeth of long-dead Europeans. The strain of herpes virus that causes lip sores in people today — called HSV-1 — was once thought to have emerged in Africa more than 50,000 years ago. But the new data, published in Science Advances on 27 July1, indicate that its origin was much more recent: around 5,000 years ago during the Bronze Age.' back

Jeffrey Nicholls (1967), How universal is the universe?, ' 61 The future is beyond our comprehension, but we can get an idea of it and speed its coming by studying what we already have. Contemplating the size and wonder of the universe as it stands in the light of its openness to the future must surely be a powerful incentive to men to love God. We have come a long way since the little world of St Thomas. Ours is open to all things, even participating in god. This is what I mean by universal. ' back

John McKay, Sweden has broken its neutrality convention and sided with Ukraine. Does this matter?, ' Sweden’s decision to apply for NATO membership following Russia’s invasion of Ukraine has generally been greeted with enthusiasm, as a further demonstration of Western unity in the face of Vladimir Putin’s aggression. But even two years ago, such a step would have been unthinkable. Since the end of the Napoleonic Wars in 1814, Sweden had asserted a firm policy of neutrality that involved non-participation in any wars and an avoidance of alliances during peacetime. For Swedes, neutrality was at the centre of their identity and their perception of their special place in the world. Their new position will inevitably involve some psychological readjustments. However, for the rest of us, there are also some significant costs that flow from the end of Swedish neutrality.' back

Julia Yost, New York’s Hottest Club Is the Catholic Church, ' As senior churchmen seek to make Catholicism palatable to modernity, members of a small but significant scene are turning to the ancient faith in defiance of liberal pieties. The scene is often associated with “Dimes Square,” a downtown Manhattan neighborhood popular with a pandemic-weary Generation Z — or Zoomer — crowd, but it has spread across a network of podcasts and upstart publications. Its sensibility is more transgressive than progressive. Many of its denizens profess to be apolitical. Others hold outré opinions, whether sincerely or as fashion statements. Reactionary motifs are chic: Trump hats and “tradwife” frocks, monarchist and anti-feminist sentiments. Perhaps the ultimate expression of this contrarian aesthetic is its embrace of Catholicism.' back

Michèle Dominici, Becoming Marilyn, On the 60th anniversary of Marilyn Monroe's passing, this documentary provides a unique portrait of the screen icon from her own perspective. In contrast to the many films made and books written about her, this one offers to give her back her voice, through the interviews she gave, the books she wrote and the fragments she left behind. For the first time, it will be a matter of understanding how Norma Jeane Baker created the iconic Marilyn Monroe. Because Marilyn was not born Marilyn, she became her. back

Paul Baumann, Transgressive Traditionalists, ; The Times’s most recent effort to provide a glimpse of how traditional Catholics think comes from Julia Yost, a senior editor at First Things. Yost’s op-ed is titled “New York’s Hottest Club Is the Catholic Church.” She describes a Manhattan “scene” frequented by young Catholic-curious artists and intellectuals and propelled by “a network of podcasts and upstart publications.” Unlike “senior churchmen,” who mistakenly try to “make Catholicism palatable to modernity,” these nascent Catholics are “more transgressive than progressive.” The soulless tyranny of secular liberalism is once again in the dock. “Reactionary motifs are chic: Trump hats and ‘tradwife’ frocks, monarchist and anti-feminist sentiments".' back

Recovery of Aristotle - Wikipedia, Recovery of Aristotle - Wikipedia, the free encclopedia , 'The "Recovery of Aristotle" (or Rediscovery) refers to the copying or re-translating of most of Aristotle's books (of ancient Greece), from Greek or Arabic text into Latin, during the Middle Ages, of the Latin West. The Recovery of Aristotle spanned about 100 years, from the middle 12th century into the 13th century, and copied or translated over 42 books (see: Corpus Aristotelicum), including Arabic texts from Arabic authors, where the previous Latin versions had only two books in general circulation: Categories and On Interpretation (De Interpretatione).' back

Samantha Hepburn, Opening 10 new oil and gas sites is a win for fossil fuel companies – but a staggering loss for the rest of Australia, ' King’s announcement came at a resources conference in Darwin, where she said: Gas enables greater use of renewables domestically by providing energy security. Australian [liquefied natural gas] is also a force for regional energy security and helps our trading partners meet their own decarbonisation goals. The problem with this assessment is that it ignores two things. First, Australia exports nearly 90% of domestically produced gas and lacks robust export controls to moderate this. Without these controls, increasing domestic production will not improve Australia’s energy security. Second, gas can only enable greater use of renewables domestically and provide energy security where it is “decarbonised” through the use of carbon-capture and storage. If it isn’t decarbonised, using gas undermines energy security by risking further global warming. However the deployment of CCS technology is complex, expensive and faces many barriers. To date it has a history of over-promising and under-delivering.' back

Thales of Miletus - Wikipedia, Thales of Miletus - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia, ' Thales of Miletus (Greek: Θαλῆς (ὁ Μιλήσιος), c. 624/623 – c. 548/545 BC) was a Greek mathematician, astronomer and pre-Socratic philosopher from Miletus in Ionia, Asia Minor. He was one of the Seven Sages of Greece. Many, most notably Aristotle, regarded him as the first philosopher in the Greek tradition, and he is otherwise historically recognized as the first individual in Western civilization known to have entertained and engaged in scientific philosophy.
Thales was a hylozoist (one who thinks that matter is alive, i.e. containing soul(s). Aristotle wrote (De Anima 411 a7-8) of Thales: " Thales thought all things are full of gods." ' back

The Wannsee Conference (film) - Wikipedia, The Wannsee Conference (film) - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia, ' The Wannsee Conference (German: Die Wannseekonferenz) is a 1984 German TV film portraying the events of the Wannsee Conference, held in Berlin in January 1942. The script is derived from the minutes of the meeting.[1] Since no verbatim transcription of the meeting exists, the dialogue is necessarily fictionalised. The main theme of the film is the bureaucratic nature of the genocide.' back

www.naturaltheology.net is maintained by The Theology Company Proprietary Limited ACN 097 887 075 ABN 74 097 887 075 Copyright 2000-2022 © Jeffrey Nicholls