Natural Theology

We have just published a new website that develops the ideas of this site. Available at Cognitive Cosmology.com.

Contact us: Click to email

Notes

Sunday 12 November 2023 - Saturday 18 November 2023

[page 367]

Sunday 12 November 2023

The whole thing with practical technology is to make things work

[page 368]

and this means producing a continuous chain of steps from start to end, ie a deterministic computation so the P versus NP thing is applicable here. Cousins party, Dunreath, Finiss, SA 5255. P versus NP problem - Wikipedia

Monday 13 November 2023

The rotating Earth brings another dawn, modulated by the local atmosphere. The effect of gravitation is to create closed local orbits that are relatively stable with secular variations which may eventually lead to collapse. We may be halfway through the 10 billion year episode of planetary humanity. I am 80% through my personal century,

Einstein March 1905c: 'most disordered state imaginable' means the probabilities of different elements of the state are completely independent of one another.' This, given no constraint in the energy of the radiation, leads to infinite energy (the ultraviolet catastrophe) and the cosmological constant problem. Albert Einstein (1905c): On a heuristic point of view concerning the production and transformation of light, Cosmological constant problem - Wikipedia

Tuesday 14 November 2023

cc23_quantum_field : got started at last after a week reading Pais 1982 and 1986. Abraham Pais (1982): 'Subtle is the Lord...': The Science and Life of Albert Einstein, Pais (1986) Inward Bound: Of Matter and Forces in the Physical World

Wednesday 15 November 2023

I seem to have gone very zen on myself, waking with an empty mind and no enthusiasm to write except to make this note to diary. Maybe I am too comfortable. I have been looking at

[page 369]

my web stats and they are creeping up as they have done toward the end of previous years. My input is probably negligible, but it exists and I am still hoping to keep going for another 20 years. My problem always is that I have gone too far and am due to fall. My answer is that science begins with poetry. I am a product of the Universe, I am trying to understand a child of God. Of course delusion is commonplace in religion but I look around the room at all the books I regularly cite in these pages and feel consistent with them. I feel a vague need to write my own book but as long as I have a work in progress the fluidity of the internet is my friend. So hopefully my fortune on the market will increase a few hundred today, I will put the rubbish bins out and make a bit of progress on cc23_quantum_field.

The next point. The failure of the Christian claim that the structureless divinity can be omniscient and the role of matter in the representation of spirit. The fundamental particles live in a world of their own, surviving in the environment that they have created for themselves constrained by nothing but consistency fed by the perpetual creativity of divinity. Like every layer in the evolutionary system, they are both self sufficient (ie hardware) And producers of the tools to create the next layer above themselves. What we are seeking at this point is some sort of order in the 4 forces, ie

[page 370]

the four communication protocols of the universe, beginning with the universal codeless communication of gravitation, and rising to the electrodynamic layer that forms the visible world. So the next section of cc23 is to be a repeat of the layered network paradigm outlined in cc19_network I.

I have somewhat painted myself into a corner by seeking to criticize electroweak theory which is seriously complex, so I have no choice but to make a few ignorant comments and then present the Turing vacuum idea followed by more criticism of QFT in general based on the vacuum and the so called 'Planck era' I have no choice if I am to finish cognitive cosmology this month and revise Scientific Theology (perhaps renamed cognitive cosmogenesis) in December. Planck units - Wikipedia

Thursday 16 November 2023

Gradually settling on a theme for cc23_quantum_field : particles are the bearers of information, in the sense of algorithms that transform, ie encode and decode information and their role in a divine universe is to represent the spirit of God. A bit far fetched, but this seems to be consistent with the idea that our God, the initial singularity, the quantum of action, starts off omnipotent but empty and ignorant but gradually populates themself with meaning, the observable Universe, a large network of connected and connecting particles. Beginning

[page [ 371]

historically with Democritus's atom, Planck's quantum and JJ Thompson who began the modern era of particle physics. By making Hilbert space the foundation of Minkowski space, it seems that we can finally reveal the natural simplicity of quantum mechanics. The heuristic of simplicity is a hint in this direction.

Dirac found that the Lagrangian deals with phase / time alone and not the dimensions of space. Feynman used this idea to develop the path integral version of quantum theory. P. A. M. Dirac (1933): The Lagrangian in Quantum Mechanics, Path integral formulation - Wikipedia

The quantum of action is the natural unit of phase which is equivalent to a full circle of the polar complex plane.

This is the key to everything that Dirac knew and explains the linearity of quantum mechanics which cuts through relativity via the relativistic invariance of the lagrangian. That is all we need to know. A particle is an algorithm a complete logical equation, perhaps closed and lasting forever like a proton or an undisturbed atom.

Einstein via Planck dicovered the path integral, in effect. Dirac's insight was picked up by Feynman. The completeness and linearity of phase gets rid of all the rubbish about infinity and renormalization.

[page 372]

The relativistic invariance of the lagrangian arises because it works in Hilbert space outside space-time where relativity resides.

The fundamental requirement that the phase energy is nhν means an integral number of quanta of action. This is always the requirement in a logical system when a definite number of binary steps are required to execute a particular algorithm. We defocus the pendulum-swing of a move into binary, p / not-p

It seems to me that so much of the talk about quantum mechanics overlooks the fact that it is all in Hilbert space and all the events between two particles are normalized to 1 and amount to just one quantum of action whose period is a measure of the energy involved. So we keep going back to the lagrangian and the path integral. Why wouldn't Feynman simplify quantum field theory enough to get rid of normalization? Because he was thinking about distances and integrals in space rather than logical space. How does phase represent information? One way that we can look at it is by sampling amplitudes in volt-amperes at particular points in waves.

An exciting idea is like an orgasm, leaves one a bit flat afterwards.

END of DB 89 → DB 90 Hylopsychism BEGIN DB 90

[page 1]

Friday 17 November 2023
cc23_quantum_field: True to form starting new notebook, lost. cc22_network_QED is a summary of Feynman's book on QED, introducing the notion of quantum field theory in the context of a quantum mechanical foundation of the universal classical network described in cc19-Network_I which is a slight extension of my honours thesis and concludes with the properties of networks. cc20_memory is an essay on evolution, treating Hilbert spaced as the source of variation and quantum mechanics and life in Minkowski space as the venues of selection. cc23_matter_spirit makes the point that matter is the carrier of information which is the heart of spirit [so I call this new book, in honour of Aristotle hylopsychism]. So what is the role of cc23_quantum_field? In the back of my mind it is a critique of current quantum field theory, turning toward the development of my idea of a Turing vacuum to overcome the cosmological constant problem arising from the vacuum as understood in traditional quantum field theory, but this critical approach does not seem helpful [but on second thoughts, it is the only way]. The theological problem is the ignorance of god. The pysical problem is the creation of particles that carry the reality of god. These two poblems to be clearly united as the solution to one another. cc18_fixed_points to c24_chrmodynamics carries a lot of duplication

[page 2]

and all need to be rewritten. My last era of clear thought was cc17_gravitation. Since then I have been trying to make sense of the old outline established earlier in the year. So start again on these pages, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24. cc17_gravitation explains the interface between kinematic Hilbert space and dynamic Minkowski space, building a link between the Christian god of pure spirit and the real world of particles and matter. Richard Feynman (1988): QED: The Strange Story of Light and Matter

Perhaps we can start from here with a clear statement of the theological problem: a meaningless god, and the physical problem of a meaningless vacuum. This become cc18_physics_theology; physics meets theology, the whole point of my life's work and the title of the notebook.

Newton brought the heavens down to Earth: I want to produce a parallel work: spirit meets matter.

It may be easier to do this as a rewrite of Scientific Theology. Since cc17_gravitation, which felt like quite a breakthrough, I have felt as though I am flogging a dead horse, so this new approach might clear the air and maybe give me a publishable book.

Maybe I can do all this in the space of cc23_quantum_field and use it to summarize the story so far and draw the lessons.

[page 3]

So 23.1: Uniting physics and theology, ie matter and Spirit (we are going for a radical change in both disciplines).

23.2: The meeting point, cognitive cosmogenesis, quantum information and computation.

23.3: The ignorant god and evolution (ie the power of evolution).

[23.4: Slip in the cosmological constant problem here.]

23.5: Omnipotence is non-contradiction.

23.6: Gravitation is not quantized, continuous and dynamic, god's power.

23.7 Logic, mathematical ideals, evolution and quantum of action (fixed point) distinguish dynamic and kinematic (special kinematics) Albert Einstein (1905): On the Electrodynamics of Moving Bodies

23.8: The alternative views. Evolution circumvents explanation, hearing, lagrangian, phase, speech and Fourier analysis.

23.9: Weak force and antiparticles.

23.10: Is the Universe a catastrophe (positive and negative feedback).

Saturday 18 November 2023

cc23_quantum_field after a major mental revision. Changed from a history of physics as a science to a history of physics and the evolution of the world using the paradigm of evolution as the backbone of the story, beginning with cc12_hilbert_minkowski. I cannot tell how evolution managed this transition but because we are here in spacetime having started from a structureless initial singularity, it must have happened. An optimistic morning. Documenting a positive

[page 4]

future is more exciting than the history of a blighted past so the union of theology and physics benefits them both, theology becomes an empirical science and physics gets a spiritual motivation. Now to make the benefits come true. Barrow & Tipler (1996): The Anthropic Cosmological Principle

Advertising campaign: The Old God is Dead (Nietzsche).You will find the new God here. Long live God. If you benefit from my work please donate. (Spend $600 with Google).

Copyright:

You may copy this material freely provided only that you quote fairly and provide a link (or reference) to your source.

Further reading

Books

Barrow (1996), John D., and Frank J. Tipler, The Anthropic Cosmological Principle, Oxford University Press 1986, 1996 'This wide-ranging and detailed book explores the many ramifications of the Anthropic Cosmological Principle, covering the whole spectrum of human inquiry from Aristotle to Z bosons. Bringing a unique combination of skills and knowledge to the subject, John D. Barrow and Frank J. Tipler - two of the world's leading cosmologists - cover the definition and nature of life, the search for extraterrestrial intelligence, and the interpretation of the quantum theory in relation to the existence of observers.' 
Amazon
  back

Feynman (1988), Richard, QED: The Strange Story of Light and Matter, Princeton UP 1988 Jacket: 'Quantum electrodynamics - or QED for short - is the 'strange theory' that explains how light and electrons interact. Thanks to Richard Feynmann and his colleagues, it is also one of the rare parts of physics that is known for sure, a theory that has stood the test of time. . . . In this beautifully lucid set of lectures he provides a definitive introduction to QED.' 
Amazon
  back

Pais (1982), Abraham, 'Subtle is the Lord...': The Science and Life of Albert Einstein, Oxford UP 1982 Jacket: In this . . . major work Abraham Pais, himself an eminent physicist who worked alongside Einstein in the post-war years, traces the development of Einstein's entire ouvre. . . . Running through the book is a completely non-scientific biography . . . including many letters which appear in English for the first time, as well as other information not published before.' [Raffiniert ist der Herr Gott, aber boshaft is er nicht] 
Amazon
  back

Pais (1986), Abraham, Inward Bound: Of Matter and Forces in the Physical World, Clarendon Press, Oxford University Press 1986 Preface: 'I will attempt to describe what has been discovered and understood about the constituents of matter, the laws to which they are subject and the forces that act on them [in the period 1895-1983]. . . . I will attempt to convey that these have been times of progress and stagnation, of order and chaos, of belief and incredulity, of the conventional and the bizarre; also of revolutionaries and conservatives, of science by individuals and by consortia, of little gadgets and big machines, and of modest funds and big moneys.' AP 
Amazon
  back

Links

Al Jazeera (2023_11_15), Why is Gaza’s al-Shifa Hospital so important for the Israeli army?, ' Ever since the Israeli army’s strikes on the Gaza Strip began after the October 7 Hamas attack, the al-Shifa Hospital in the northern part of the besieged enclave has been prominently featured in the news. For the past five days, it has been at the centre of everything as Gaza’s death toll has risen, with more than 11,500 Palestinians, nearly half of them children, killed by Israeli forces. Brutal scenes are unfolding at the hospital as snipers have spent days shooting at anyone trying to move from one medical building to the other, prompting international outcries. But the Israeli army appears unfazed The significance of al-Shifa Hospital is beyond the medical. The storied medical complex, whose name translates into “House of Healing”, has been described as the beating heart of Gaza. It has been there since the time of the British rule over Palestine and became a hospital in 1946 after originally housing British army barracks. It has survived several wars and many years of Israeli occupation. Since last month, it has been denied urgently needed supplies of medicine and fuel – and that was before Israeli troops broke in and blew up its dwindling stores of medicine. Hospital staff had to bury dozens of people in a mass grave on the grounds as they were out of options. Dead bodies lie around its courtyard still. Beyond that, al-Shifa is seen as a nerve centre for the Gaza government’s administrative bodies. Health ministry officials have held press conferences amid the corpses there, and the government’s media ministry has operated out of the hospital. Al-Shifa kept its internet connectivity at times when the rest of Gaza was cut off by Israel, so it has also been a hot spot for journalists, some of whom are trapped there now. The hospital’s director and its doctors and staff have been providing constant updates whenever possible, often rejecting Israeli claims – like one on Wednesday that it had allowed aid into the hospital.' back

Albert Einstein (1905), On the Electrodynamics of Moving Bodies, An english translation of the paper that founded Special relativity. 'Examples of this sort, [in the contemporary application of Maxwell's electrodynamics to moving bodies] together with the unsuccessful attempts to discover any motion of the earth relatively to the ``light medium,'' suggest that the phenomena of electrodynamics as well as of mechanics possess no properties corresponding to the idea of absolute rest. They suggest rather that, as has already been shown to the first order of small quantities, the same laws of electrodynamics and optics will be valid for all frames of reference for which the equations of mechanics hold good.' back

Albert Einstein (1905c), On a heuristic point of view concerning the production and transformation of light, ' The wave theory of light, which operates with continuous spatial functions, has proved itself splendidly in describing purely optical phenomena and will probably never be replaced by another theory. One should keep in mind, however, that optical observations apply to time averages and not to momentary values, and it is conceivable that despite the complete confirmation of the theories of diffraction, reflection, refraction, dispersion, etc., by experiment, the theory of light, which operates with continuous spatial functions, may lead to contradictions with experience when it is applied to the phenomena of production and transformation of light. Indeed, it seems to me that the observations regarding "black-body" light, and other groups of phenomena associated with the production or conversion of light can be understood better if one assumes that the energy of light is discontinuously distributed in space.' back

Cosmological constant problem - Wikipedia, Cosmological constant problem - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia, ' In cosmology, the cosmological constant problem or vacuum catastrophe is the disagreement between the observed values of vacuum energy density (the small value of the cosmological constant) and theoretical large value of zero-point energy suggested by quantum field theory. Depending on the Planck energy cutoff and other factors, the discrepancy is as high as 120 orders of magnitude, a state of affairs described by physicists as "the largest discrepancy between theory and experiment in all of science" and "the worst theoretical prediction in the history of physics".' back

Frederica Marsi, Sunak battles Supreme Court ruling: What next for the UK’s Rwanda plan?, ' Hours after the United Kingdom’s Supreme Court ruled that the government’s plan to send asylum seekers to the African country was unlawful, Prime Minister Rishi Sunak promised to introduce emergency legislation that confirms that Rwanda is a safe country. The emergency legislation “will provide a guarantee in law that those who are relocated from the UK to Rwanda will be protected against removal from Rwanda.” It will also “ensure that people cannot further delay flights by bringing systemic challenges in our domestic courts, and stop our policy being repeatedly blocked,” Sunak told reporters on Wednesday. The announcement came as human rights groups celebrated the Supreme Court decision, stating that asylum seekers would be at “risk of ill-treatment” if sent back to their home countries once in Rwanda. A joint civil society statement signed by 140 organisations, including prominent campaign groups such as the Runnymede Trust and Liberty, had described the plan as “cruel and immoral”. “We urge the Government to immediately abandon such plans with Rwanda or with any other country, and instead protect the rights of people who have come to our country in search of sanctuary,” it said. Maddie Harris, founder of the UK-based Humans for Rights Network – which also signed the statement – said the Supreme Court had made it “abundantly clear that Rwanda causes a serious risk to individuals in terms of refoulement to countries where they may face persecution or death”. “An emergency law does not eliminate that risk. What the [UK] government is saying is: ‘We don’t care if we send people back to their death,’” she told Al Jazeera.' back

Julian Borger, IDF evidence so far falls well short of al-Shifa hospital being Hamas HQ, ' Prior to their capture of Dar al-Shifa hospital, the Israel Defense Forces went to great lengths to depict the medical complex as a headquarters for Hamas, from where its attacks on Israel were planned. The evidence produced so far falls well short of that. IDF videos have shown only modest collections of small arms, mostly assault rifles, recovered from the extensive medical complex. That suggests an armed presence, but not the sort of elaborate nerve centre depicted in animated graphics presented to the media before al-Shifa was seized, portraying a network of well-equipped subterranean chambers. Even the videos produced so far have raised questions under scrutiny. A BBC analysis found the footage of an IDF spokesperson showing the apparent discovery of a bag containing a gun behind an MRI scanning machine, had been taped hours before the arrival of the journalists to whom he was supposedly showing it. . . .. The Biden administration has not only defended Israel’s operations but presented independent claims based on its own intelligence about the hospital. John Kirby, the White House national security spokesperson, framed the alleged Hamas facility there as a command “node” rather than a centre, and a possible weapons store. The absence of evidence so far, is beginning to recall past US intelligence failures, most dramatically those preceding the Iraq invasion. It further isolates Washington on the world stage, and deepens already significant rifts within the administration itself.' back

Jürgen Knauer , Plants are likely to absorb more CO₂ in a changing climate than we thought – here’s why, ' The world’s vegetation has a remarkable ability to absorb carbon dioxide (CO₂) from the air and store it as biomass. In doing so, plants slow down climate change since the CO₂ they take up does not contribute to global warming. But what will happen under more advanced climate change? How will vegetation respond to projected changes in atmospheric CO₂, temperatures and rainfall? Our study, published today in Science Advances, shows plants might take up more CO₂ than previously thought. back

Lynley Wallia, Heather Bourke & Troy Meston, Our mapping project shows how extensive frontier violence was in Queensland. This is why truth-telling matters, ' Detachments of troopers were regularly sent out on patrol, covering large areas along the frontier of the colony in pursuit of Indigenous people who were considered to be “problematic”. Their main job was to protect civilian settlers, the lands they had taken up, and their livelihoods - by whatever means necessary. While on patrol, the Native Mounted Police are known to have engaged in violence against Aboriginal people, including killings of men, women and children, kidnappings, rape, and the forcible removal of children. Truth-telling will mean coming to terms with this violence. Their actions radically altered the makeup of First Nations groups, diminished their populations, and changed where and how survivors could live.. . . All together, we mapped more than 2,500 of these conflict events across colonial Queensland from 1623 until 1911. Our findings show violence occurred everywhere, but was especially common along the east coast and on Cape York Peninsula. . . .. Historians Raymond Evans and Robert Ørsted-Jensen have estimated some 41,000 Aboriginal people could have been killed at the hands of the Native Mounted Police between 1859 and 1897. Their estimate was based on reasonable and minimal assumptions drawn from historical documents and an average seven-year lifespan per camp. Extending the duration of a camp to 13 years, in line with our newly identified data, increases the total deaths to potentially over 60,000.' back

P versus NP problem - Wikipedia, P versus NP problem - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia, ' The P versus NP problem is a major unsolved problem in computer science. It asks whether every problem whose solution can be quickly verified (technically, verified in polynomial time) can also be solved quickly (again, in polynomial time). The underlying issues were first discussed in the 1950s, in letters from John Forbes Nash Jr. to the National Security Agency, and from Kurt Gödel to John von Neumann. The precise statement of the P versus NP problem was introduced in 1971 by Stephen Cook in his seminal paper " The complexity of theorem proving procedures" and is considered by many to be the most important open problem in the field.' back

P. A. M. Dirac (1933), The Lagrangian in Quantum Mechanics, ' . . . there is an alternative formulation [to the Hamiltonian] in classical dynamics, provided by the Lagrangian. This requires one to work in terms of coordinates and velocities instead of coordinates and momenta. The two formulation are closely related but there are reasons for believing that the Lagrangian one is more fundamental. . . . Secondly the lagrangian method can easily be expressed relativistically, on account of the action function being a relativistic invariant; . . .. ' [This article was first published in Physikalische Zeitschrift der Sowjetunion, Band 3, Heft 1 (1933), pp. 64–72.] back

Path integral formulation - Wikipedia, Path integral formulation - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia, 'The path integral formulation of quantum mechanics is a description of quantum theory which generalizes the action principle of classical mechanics. It replaces the classical notion of a single, unique trajectory for a system with a sum, or functional integral, over an infinity of possible trajectories to compute a quantum amplitude. . . . This formulation has proved crucial to the subsequent development of theoretical physics, since it provided the basis for the grand synthesis of the 1970s which unified quantum field theory with statistical mechanics. . . . ' back

Peter John McLaughlin, Suella Braverman’s comments comparing Gaza protests with Northern Ireland are a grave misunderstanding of the facts, ' Braverman later insisted she was indeed referring to dissident republicanism. And republicans do also participate in marches, but historically the most significant of these have been civil rights demonstrations to highlight the discrimination faced by the Catholic community. These marches were largely banned by the then Unionist government – something which Braverman appears to want in the case of the London protests, though she has denied this. Unionists justified their bans by making the same insinuations that Braverman makes in her Times article – that such marches can be a front for violent subversives. However, the violence triggered by civil rights marches in Northern Ireland was mainly enacted by the state – most famously and tragically of all on Bloody Sunday in January 1972, when the British army shot dead protesters, resulting in 14 deaths. The march on Bloody Sunday was a protest against the use of internment without trial in Northern Ireland. Like the freedoms of expression and assembly – both of which are exercised in the Gaza protests – freedom from unlawful imprisonment is a fundamental democratic right. Indeed it is a fundamentally British right, given its place in the Magna Carta. Worryingly, Braverman, the home secretary, and thus a key figure in upholding British law, would seem to be struggling with such concepts.' back

Planck units - Wikipedia, Planck units - Wikipedia, the free encycloedia, ' In particle physics and physical cosmology, Planck units are a set of units of measurement defined exclusively in terms of four universal physical constants, in such a manner that these physical constants take on the numerical value of 1 when expressed in terms of these units. . Originally proposed in 1899 by German physicist Max Planck, these units are also known as natural units because the origin of their definition comes only from properties of nature and not from any human construct. Planck units are only one system of several systems of natural units, but Planck units are not based on properties of any prototype object or particle (that would be arbitrarily chosen), but rather on only the properties of free space.' back

www.naturaltheology.net is maintained by The Theology Company Proprietary Limited ACN 097 887 075 ABN 74 097 887 075 Copyright 2000-2023 © Jeffrey Nicholls